- Research article
- Open Access
Anterior knee pain in younger adults as a precursor to subsequent patellofemoral osteoarthritis: a systematic review
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders volume 11, Article number: 201 (2010)
Patellofemoral osteoarthritis (PFOA) is a common form of knee OA in middle and older age, but its relation to PF disorders and symptoms earlier in life is unclear. Our aim was to conduct a systematic review to investigate the strength of evidence for an association between anterior knee pain (AKP) in younger adults and subsequent PFOA.
The search strategy included electronic databases (Pubmed, EMBASE, AMED, CINAHL, Cochrane, PEDro, SportDiscus: inception to December 2009), reference lists of potentially eligible studies and selected reviews. Full text articles in any language, - identified via English titles and abstracts, were included if they were retrospective or prospective in design and contained quantitative data regarding structural changes indicative of PFOA, incident to original idiopathic AKP. Eligibility criteria were applied to titles, abstracts and full-texts by two independent reviewers. Data extraction included study location, design, date, sampling procedure, sample characteristics, AKP/PFOA definitions, follow-up duration and rate, and main findings. Foreign language articles were translated into English prior to examination.
Seven articles satisfied eligibility (5 English, 2 German). Only one case-control study directly investigated a link between PFOA and prior AKP, providing level 3b evidence in favour of an association (OR 4.4; 95%CI 1.8, 10.6). Rough estimates of the annual risk of PFOA from the remaining six small, uncontrolled, observational studies (mean follow-up range: 5.7 to 23 years) ranged from 0% to 3.4%. This was not the primary aim of these studies, and limitations in design and methodology mean this data should be interpreted with caution.
There is a paucity of high-quality evidence reporting a link between AKP and PFOA. Further, well-designed cohort studies may be able to fill this evidence gap.
Patellofemoral osteoarthritis (PFOA) is increasingly recognised to be a common, early form of knee OA in middle and old age, associated with symptoms and functional limitation . While OA research tends to focus on this older age group, our understanding of the aetiology of PFOA may benefit from taking a broader view of events, exposures, morphology, and morbidity related to the patellofemoral joint earlier in life. We take as our starting point the investigation of whether PFOA is associated with previous anterior knee pain (AKP) in youth.
The classification and terminology surrounding patellofemoral disorders is contentious. "Anterior knee pain" is a broad symptom classification and a term about which there is arguably some agreement and acceptance among clinical researchers. It does not imply any particular diagnosis or physical condition and is likely to be multifactorial . One Finnish study estimated the prevalence of AKP in childhood and adolescence at 19% , although prevalence estimates generally cited in the published literature vary widely, from 3% to 40% . In such age groups AKP has traditionally been viewed as benign and self-limiting . However, there is an increasing body of evidence to challenge this view. Stathopulu & Baildam  and Price et al.  both found that in excess of 90% of the AKP sufferers in their studies had ongoing problems at least four years later, while Sandow & Goodfellow reported that 94% of their sample continued to experience difficulties for a mean 16 years following diagnosis . These studies do not provide evidence of a link between AKP in youth and the subsequent development of PFOA but they do highlight that AKP may have longer-term repercussions than previously thought.
Potentially plausible mechanisms linking AKP to PFOA include shared biomechanical risk factors, such as malalignment and muscular dysfunction. These are acknowledged risk factors for AKP that are also thought to be important in the pathogenesis of PFOA [8–10]. Other potential mechanisms include cumulative mechanical loading and micro-trauma and proprioceptive deficits. These remain relatively speculative. Our aim was not to test causal hypotheses but simply to systematically review the literature to describe the strength of evidence for a temporal association between AKP in younger adults and the subsequent development of PFOA. A clearly demonstrable association would provide impetus for further research on the underlying mechanisms with possible implications for the routine management of AKP problems and more widespread use of potential preventive strategies.
Full-text articles in any language, identified via English titles and abstracts, dealing with in vivo human studies reported in international peer-reviewed journals were considered for inclusion. Foreign language articles were translated into English prior to review. To be included, studies had to contain quantitative data regarding structural changes indicative of PFOA (such as joint space narrowing, presence of osteophytes, subchondral sclerosis and cartilage defects), incident to original idiopathic AKP. Both prospective and retrospective designs were considered suitable for inclusion; cross-sectional studies and follow-up studies of patients who had undergone surgical interventions were not.
Title and abstract searches were conducted in the following electronic databases from inception to December 2009: Pubmed, EMBASE, AMED, CINAHL, Cochrane, PEDro and SportDiscus. The following search terms were used for osteoarthritis: osteoarthritis, osteoarthrosis, arthritis, arthrosis, gonarthritis, gonarthrosis, total knee replacement, TKR, arthroplasty. Each of these terms was paired in turn with the following terms designed to capture all possible studies of anterior knee pain and related patellofemoral disorders: anterior knee pain, patellofemoral pain, patellofemoral arthropathy, chondromalacia patellae, jumpers knee. This strategy was supplemented by hand searching the reference lists of all full-text articles obtained and selected review articles. We cross-checked our search strategy by running additional searches in Pubmed using search terms from two published Cochrane systematic reviews of exercise therapy for patellofemoral pain syndrome  and knee osteoarthritis .
Two authors (MT and LW) independently reviewed all potentially relevant articles by title and abstract. Articles not excluded by both reviewers at this stage were obtained in full-text for detailed inspection. If agreement regarding inclusion could not be reached the fourth author (GP) acted as arbiter.
Data extraction and synthesis
Data extraction included study location, design and date, sampling procedure and sample characteristics, AKP and PFOA definitions, follow-up duration, follow-up rate and main findings. Two authors (MT and LW) independently performed data extraction and then met to synthesise their findings. Disagreements were resolved via fourth author (GP) arbitration. Where possible within-study odds ratios or annual risk estimates were calculated to enable comparisons to be made between studies.
Studies included in the review were categorised using a conventional level of evidence hierarchy , which ranges from Level 1a (systematic reviews (with homogeneity) of randomised controlled trials) to Level 5 evidence (expert opinion without explicit critical appraisal, or based on physiology, bench research or "first principles"). In addition, two authors (MT and LW) independently employed the Critical Review Form - Quantitative Studies to assess the internal and external validity of included studies [14, 15]. Using the 15 closed-ended questions, study quality was assessed by assigning "1" (indicating criterion completely fulfilled) or "0" (indicating criterion not fulfilled) to each question. These were then summed to generate a total score out of 15 [16, 17]. Disagreements between the two reviewers were resolved via fourth author (GP) arbitration.
The initial search identified 2920 potentially relevant articles, of which 2764 were excluded based on title and abstract. Full texts of 156 articles were independently reviewed by two authors (see Figure 1). Seven studies met all the inclusion criteria [18–24], one of these emerging from reference list screening . Five studies were in English [18–20, 22, 24], and two were in German [21, 23]. The design characteristics of the seven studies are presented in Table 1[25–27]. The cross-checking search identified five more potentially eligible studies which, on inspection of their full text, provided no quantitative data relevant to the present research question.
One case-control study provided level 3b evidence ; the other six provided level 4 evidence, being prospective follow-ups of case series [19–24], one of participants in a randomised controlled trial (RCT) . Three of the six prospective studies compared the long-term outcomes of participants with conservatively treated AKP versus those with operatively managed AKP [21, 23, 24]. For these three, only the data regarding the conservatively treated participants are reported here. The results of the studies' methodological quality assessment, according to Law et al.'s  Critical Review Form - Quantitative Studies, is presented in Table 2. Only four of the seven studies scored 8 or above out of the total possible score of 15 [18–20, 22]. The other three scored between 3 and 5 [21, 23, 24], suggesting poor methodological quality. In particular, in only three out of the seven studies was the sample described in detail [18, 22, 23] and in only three were any limitations of the study acknowledged [18, 19, 22]. Definitions of AKP depended on clinical history and physical examination in four of the seven studies [19, 20, 22, 24], but in only two of the seven was a specific definition of AKP provided [18, 19], one of these being the recall of AKP as a child, teenager, or young adult .
The results of the seven studies are summarised in Table 3. Only the retrospective case-control study had as its explicitly stated aim the investigation of a link between idiopathic adolescent AKP and PFOA . This study compared the recall of adolescent AKP among 118 cases who had undergone patellofemoral arthroplasty for isolated PFOA, with an unmatched group of 116 'controls' who had undergone medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. Compared with controls, cases were more likely to report AKP during adolescence (22% versus 6%, crude OR 4.4: 95%CI 1.8, 10.6).
The study by Kannus et al  - a 7-year follow-up of participants in an RCT of non-operative treatments for patellofemoral pain syndrome, reported a 70% follow-up rate of participants who received imaging at baseline (37 out of 53). Plain radiographs and MRI scans were taken of the patellofemoral joints of all 37 participants. Although some degree of structural abnormality consistent with PFOA changes was found to be present in 13 of the 37 (35%) using MRI, in only two cases (5%) were these changes deemed to be indicative of severe PFOA. A similar prevalence for severe PFOA was observed for x-rays (3%). Of the five long-term follow-ups of case series, plain x-rays of the patellofemoral joint were available in varying proportions of the samples [20–24]. Four of the five reported follow-up radiographic data on less than a third of the original sample [20, 21, 23, 24]. Two studies reported no radiographic changes [20, 22], while three documented changes consistent with PFOA in 12%, 20% and 48% of cases at 13, 5.9 and 23 years of follow-up, respectively [23, 24, 21].
With the exception of the case-control study by Utting et al.  the number of participants in the studies was low, generally numbering between 22 and 37 (although one study did only have eight participants ). Follow-up rates were also often poor because of the intervening time-lag: three of the studies had follow-up rates of less than 20% [20, 21, 23].
These findings reveal a paucity of high-quality research evidence regarding the link between idiopathic AKP in younger adults and the subsequent development of PFOA. The results of Utting et al.'s  case-control study provide some evidence for this link. While the accuracy of individuals' recall is an issue in such studies, the choice of a suitable control group (comprising individuals undergoing medial unicompartmental arthroplasty) is likely to have minimised recall bias.
The results of the remaining six studies should be interpreted with caution for a number of reasons, including issues of small sample size, poor follow-up rates, absence of control groups and samples containing individuals with traumatic AKP. It should be noted that in some cases studies were so selective about which participants they chose to follow up with x-ray investigations that their use in evaluating the existence of a link between idiopathic AKP and subsequent PFOA is questionable. Hvid et al.  only followed up individuals with "a significant clinical syndrome" of chondromalacia patellae confirmed on arthrograms, possibly suggesting pre-existing patellofemoral arthropathy, while participants invited for x-ray follow-up by Nimon et al.  were only that small proportion of 14 out of 49 whose symptoms had got no better over the years. Furthermore, in five studies either the imaging views are not specified [21, 23, 24] or the criteria by which PFOA was judged to be present or absent are not stated [20, 22, 24]. Additional limitations include the lack of substantive definitions of AKP and PFOA in many cases. The unclear clinical significance of mild structural abnormalities, for example the 35% 7-year incidence of any MRI changes in the study by Kannus et al. , also requires cautious interpretation, particularly in the absence of control groups with no AKP at the time of recruitment.
Agreed quality checklists, such as that used in the current review, can provide a profile of a research study report that draws attention to its particular methodological strengths and weaknesses . Most of the studies in this review failed to satisfy several of the methodological quality criteria in this checklist. This is partly due to the fact that such tools necessarily tend to reflect the quality of reporting of data relevant to a clear principal research question. Most of the studies included in this review either did not have a clear research question beyond a general descriptive epidemiological remit, or they reported data regarding AKP and PFOA that was incidental to their main purpose.
The studies identified in this review underscore the major challenges in designing and conducting prospective studies to answer the question of whether there may be an association between AKP in younger adulthood and the development of PFOA later in life. These are 1) recruiting a representative sample, 2) using standardised definitions of AKP and PFOA to both an exposure group and a comparable control group, 3) performing x-rays at baseline to confirm the absence of PFOA in AKP sufferers at this stage 4) ensuring adequate follow-up and low attrition over a long period. While such studies as those identified in this review can hint at the possibility of an association between AKP in younger adults and the subsequent development of PFOA in later life, a clear causal relationship cannot be established by them.
Several limitations in our study deserve comment. Firstly, the majority of studies identified by this review did not directly investigate the link between AKP and PFOA. It is therefore possible that some studies excluded by title and abstract search could also contain additional data without having given explicit focus to this question. Secondly, we did not formally attempt to quantify the level of agreement between reviewers either in the selection of articles for inclusion or in the methodological quality assessment.
In summary, there is a lack of sound evidence from epidemiological studies on the association between AKP in younger adults and subsequent PFOA. What evidence there is comes from one case-control study. Much of the other 'evidence' relating to this research question is tentative, exploratory, even incidental to the authors' main objectives, and is therefore still subject to confirmation or falsification with less biased study designs in larger samples. The possibility that AKP is a risk factor for incident PFOA warrants further attention. Future well-designed analyses, conducted within population-based studies are needed. It is possible that existing longitudinal studies with actual or potential AKP and PFOA data may be capable of addressing this question.
Duncan RC, Hay EM, Saklatvala J, Croft PR: Prevalence of radiographic osteoarthritis--it all depends on your point of view. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2006, 45: 757-760. 10.1093/rheumatology/kei270.
Grelsamer R, Moss G, Ee G, Donell S: The patellofemoral syndrome; the same problem as the loch ness monster?. Knee. 2009, 16: 301-302. 10.1016/j.knee.2009.05.005.
Vahasarja V: Prevalence of chronic knee pain in children and adolescents in northern Finland. Acta Paediatr. 1995, 84: 803-805. 10.1111/j.1651-2227.1995.tb13760.x.
Callaghan MJ, Selfe J: Has the incidence or prevalence of patellofemoral pain in the general population in the United Kingdom been properly evaluated?. Phys Ther Sport. 2007, 8: 37-43. 10.1016/j.ptsp.2006.07.001.
Sandow MJ, Goodfellow JW: The natural history of anterior knee pain in adolescents. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1985, 67: 36-38.
Stathopulu E, Baildam E: Anterior knee pain: a long term follow-up. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2003, 42: 380-382. 10.1093/rheumatology/keg093.
Price AJ, Jones J, Allum R: Chronic traumatic anterior knee pain. Injury. 2000, 31: 373-378. 10.1016/S0020-1383(00)00006-1.
Witvrouw E, Werner S, Mikkelsen C, Van Tiggelen D, Vanden Berghe L, Cerulli G: Clinical classification of patellofemoral pain syndrome: guidlines for non-operative treatment. Knee Surg, Sports Traumatol, Arthrosc. 2005, 13: 122-130. 10.1007/s00167-004-0577-6.
Berry PA, Teichtahl AJ, Wulka AE, Cicuttini FM: The role of biomechanical factors on patellofemoral osteoarthritis. Cur Rheumatol Rev. 2007, 3: 123-127. 10.2174/157339707780619368.
Crossley KM, Vicenzino B, Pandy MG, Schache AG, Hinman RS: Targeted physiotherapy for patellofemoral joint osteoarthritis: a protocol for a randomised, single-blind controlled trial. BMC Musculoskeletal Disord. 2008, 9: 122-10.1186/1471-2474-9-122.
Heintjes EM, Berger M, Bierma-Zeinstra SMA, Bernsen RMD, Verhaar JAN, Koes BW: Exercise therapy for patellofemoral pain syndrome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2003, 4: CD003472-
Fransen M, McConnell S: Exercise for osteoarthritis of the knee. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2008, 4: CD004376-
Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine. Levels of Evidence. 2009, [http://www.cebm.net/index.aspx?o=1025%20accessed%2016/07/10]
Law M, Stewart D, Pollock N, Letts L, Bosch J, Westmorland M: Critical Review Form - Quantitative Studies. 1998, [http://www.srs-mcmaster.ca/Portals/20/pdf/ebp/quanreview.pdf]
Katrak P, Bialocerkowski AE, Massey-Westropp N, Kumar S, Grimmer KA: A systematic review of the content of critical appraisal tools. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2004, 4: 22-10.1186/1471-2288-4-22.
Bialocerkowski AE, Vladusic SL, Wei NC: Prevalence, risk factors, and natural history of positional plagiocephaly: a systematic review. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2008, 50: 577-586. 10.1111/j.1469-8749.2008.03029.x.
Bialocerkowski AE, Kurlowicz K, Vladusic SL, Grimmer KA: The effectiveness of conservative management for infants with obstetric brachial plexus palsy. Int J Evidence Based Health Care. 2005, 3: 27-44. 10.1111/j.1479-6988.2005.00020.x.
Utting MR, Davies G, Newman JH: Is anterior knee pain a predisposing factor to patellofemoral osteoarthritis?. Knee. 2005, 12: 362-365. 10.1016/j.knee.2004.12.006.
Kannus P, Natri A, Paakkala T, Jarvinen M: An outcome study of chronic patellofemoral pain syndrome. Seven-year follow-up of patients in a randomized, controlled trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1999, 81: 355-363.
Nimon G, Murray D, Sandow M, Goodfellow JW: Natural history of anterior knee pain: A 14- to 20-year follow-up of nonoperative management. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics. 1998, 18: 118-122. 10.1097/00004694-199801000-00021.
Imhoff A, Boni T: [The femoropatellar pain syndrome. Conservative and surgical therapy in a long-term comparison (10-20 years) and their therapeutic consequences] [Article in German]. Z Orthop Ihre Grenzgeb. 1989, 127: 139-151. 10.1055/s-2008-1040102.
Hvid I, Andersen LI, Schmidt H: Chondromalacia patellae. The relation to abnormal patellofemoral joint mechanics. Acta Orthop Scand. 1981, 52: 661-666. 10.3109/17453678108992164.
Dexel M, Osterwalder M, Zollinger H: [Comparative results of a long-term follow-up of patellar chondropathy 15 years after conservative and operative treatment] [Article in German]. Orthop Praxis. 1980, 16: 552-560.
Karlson S: Chondromalacia patellae. Acta Chir Scandinav. 1939, 83: 347-381.
Jäger M, Wirth CJ: [Capsule-Band Lesions, Biomechanics, Diagnosis and Therapy] [Article in German]. 1978, Stuttgart: Thieme
Merchant AC, Mercer RL, Jacobsen RH, Cool CR: Roentgenographic analysis of patellofemoral congruence. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1974, 56: 1391-1396.
Tapper EM, Hoover NW: Late results after meniscectomy. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1969, 51: 517-526.
Downs SH, Black N: The feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions. J Epidemiol Community Health. 1998, 52: 377-384. 10.1136/jech.52.6.377.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2474/11/201/prepub
This work was funded by a Programme Grant awarded by Arthritis Research UK (18174) and a Nursing, Midwifery, and Allied Health Professionals Research Training Award (NMAHP/RTS/09/15) from West Midlands Strategic Health Authority to Martin Thomas.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
All authors participated in the study design and analysis, and drafting of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Thomas, M.J., Wood, L., Selfe, J. et al. Anterior knee pain in younger adults as a precursor to subsequent patellofemoral osteoarthritis: a systematic review. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 11, 201 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2474-11-201
- Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty
- Anterior Knee Pain
- Patellofemoral Joint
- Methodological Quality Assessment