- Research article
- Open Access
Arthroscopic-assisted reduction, bone grafting and screw fixation across the scapholunate joint for proximal pole scaphoid nonunion
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders volume 21, Article number: 834 (2020)
There are some difficulties in treating proximal scaphoid nonunion, mainly including poor vascularity of the proximal scaphoid fragment and limited space for a stable fixation in the proximal scaphoid fragment. This study reports the outcomes of treating proximal scaphoid nonunion with arthroscopic assist for reduction, bone grafting and screw fixation across the scapholunate (SL) joint.
Between 2008 and 2017, 21 patients were enrolled. Fracture healing and change in the lateral SL angle and SL gap were evaluated. Functional outcomes were evaluated using the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score, wrist range of motion, grip strength, and the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) for pain.
Nineteen patients achieved fracture healing and their mean follow-up duration was 31.3 months (24–120 months). The average fracture healing time was 16.3 weeks (10 to 28 weeks). From the preoperative to the postoperative final evaluation, there was some significant improvement in wrist function, including wrist flexion from 54.5o to 67.4o, wrist extension from 62.3o to 71.7o, DASH scores from 52.4 to 21.4, VAS during activity from 4.6 to 2.1, and grip strength from 9.6 kg to 24.7 kg. The lateral SL angle also improved significantly, from 82o to 66o. Seventeen patients requested screw removal after fracture healing because of their cultural belief in not leaving hardware in the body. No significant SL gap widening was noted after screw removal in the sequential follow-ups.
Using arthroscopic-assisted reduction, bone grafting and screw fixation across the SL joint in proximal scaphoid nonunion treatment, satisfactory functional and radiographic outcomes can be achieved.
The scaphoid has a unique intraosseous retrograde blood flow, and it connects with the lunate in the proximal row to sustain axial loading of the wrist . From 5 to 15% of all scaphoid fractures develop to nonunion [2, 3]. Scaphoid nonunion can cause changes in wrist mechanics and uncoupling of carpal rows, eventually progressing to scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC) . SNAC change was found in 97% of patients with at least 5 years of scaphoid nonunion . Treatment for scaphoid nonunion includes non-vascularized bone grafts, pedicle vascularized grafts, free flaps, and total arthroscopic management. The majority of reports for each method indicates high union rates of more than 90%, but there is still debate regarding which treatment is better for patients [2, 3, 6].
If a proximal scaphoid fracture failed to heal, there would be some important issues to be concerned about in the treatment, including poor vascularity of the proximal scaphoid fragment or avascular necrosis of the scaphoid, and limited space for stable fixation in the proximal fragment [7,8,9].
There have been several reports regarding treatment methods for proximal scaphoid nonunion. Both vascularized and non-vascularized bone graft combined with scaphoid screw or K-wires fixation are commonly used methods [10,11,12,13,14,15,16]. Precise and stable fixation of the small proximal fragment with the larger distal fragment is mostly achievable, but many surgeons still consider fixation in a small fragment to be a difficult procedure.
The reduction-association of the scapholunate joint (RASL) method has been proposed as a treatment for chronic scapholunate (SL) interosseous ligament (SLIL) injury , using either an open or arthroscopic (ARASL) method with headless screw fixation across the SL joint after denuding the space between the scaphoid and the lunate . Screw transfixation from the scaphoid to the lunate has also been reported as a way to overcome the difficulty of fixing the proximal scaphoid nonunion [9, 19].
Since arthroscopic treatment for scaphoid nonunion has become more commonly used, we designed this study to evaluate the outcomes of arthroscopic-assisted reduction, bone grafting and, using a small incision at the anatomic snuffbox region, screw fixation across the SL joint in treating proximal scaphoid nonunion.
This study was approved by the ethics committee of our institution. We retrospectively evaluated cases of proximal scaphoid nonunion that were treated with arthroscopic-assisted bone grafting and headless compression screw fixation across the SL joint. All surgeries were performed by 2 hand surgeons (experience level III – experienced specialist) .
All patients underwent radiographic and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) evaluation of their wrists preoperatively. We defined nonunion in our enrollment criteria as a persistently non-healed fracture 6 months after the trauma, based on radiographic findings. Inclusion criteria were (1) patients with a nonunion of a proximal scaphoid fracture, type I or type II, according to the Schernberg classification , (2) patients with no or only stage I SNAC , and (3) any age or gender.
Exclusion criteria were (1) stages II to IV SNAC or mid-carpal instability, and (2) patients without follow-up for 2 years or without complete medical records. Patients with more advanced SNAC may be suitable for proximal row carpectomy or some arthrodesis procedures. Patients with mid-carpal instability should undergo ligament tensioning procedures, and this may interfere with functional outcomes.
The surgical procedure was performed under general anesthesia and pneumatic tourniquet control with the forearm on the traction tower. The midcarpal portals were used for assessment and treatment of the scaphoid. Debridement of the nonunion site was performed with curette, burr, and shaver, until normal cancellous bone with punctate bleeding was observed.
If there was dorsal intercalated segmental instability (DISI), reduction of the lunate together with the fractured scaphoid proximal fragment was performed. Then, temporary transfixing of the radius and lunate was achieved by pinning from the dorsal aspect of the distal radius to the lunate.
If there was flexion and pronation of the distal scaphoid fragment, we would perform traction of the thumb and manually push on the scaphoid at the scaphoid tubercle, with force applied from palmar to dorsal. Then, temporary transfixing of the distal scaphoid fragment and the capitate or the lunate from the radial side of the scaphoid was performed to maintain the reduction hands-free. Our preference is to perform scaphocapitate transfixation. Positioning of these wires should be eccentric to avoid hindering the subsequent placement of the SL screw. It is important not to injure the surrounding vital tissues when setting the K-wires; using a small incision with instruments such as the Mosquito forceps for protection would be helpful.
We used the dry arthroscopy method when performing bone grafting. We harvested the autologous cancellous bone grafts (8 cases from the iliac crest and 13 from the distal radius) and cut them into small chips. The bone graft of the distal radius was harvested from the volar side through a small incision, about 2–3 cm in length. Then, we delivered the bone graft into the nonunion gap using a 2.9 mm arthroscopic cannula. A small freer elevator can be used to compress the bone graft to fill the bone defect.
Then, a cannulated headless compression screw was introduced via a small incision at the anatomic snuffbox region to transfix the fracture site and cross the SL interval under fluoroscopic guidance  (Fig. 1). Either a Herbert screw, a 3.0 mm Headless Compression Screw (HCS) (DePuy Synthes, West Chester, PA, USA) (Fig. 2), or an Acutrak Standard (Acumed, OR, USA) screw was used for fixation (Fig. 3). Radial styloidectomy could be performed in the same, but more extended, screw insertion wound to gain better access or if the patients had symptoms of early-stage SNAC. Our incision for screw insertion is about 0.5 cm in length, and it can be extended to 1–2 cm proximally and volarly if the radial styloid is to be addressed. It is important that after setting the guide pin and screw, arthroscopic checking of the reduction and that the hardware has not penetrated the midcarpal joint should be performed. We did not aim to perform screw fixation through the center of the proximal scaphoid fragment. The goal was to have good headless screw fixation in the bigger part of the distal scaphoid fragment and the lunate, with the proximal fragment immobilized and fixed between them.
A removable short-arm thumb spica splint was applied postoperatively for 2 months, and then was intermittently used, depending on the condition of fracture healing and the patient’s rehabilitation. Rehabilitation programs with active gentle wrist range of motion exercise were initiated 2 months after surgery. Strengthening programs and a gradual return to unrestricted activities were allowed when union was radiographically confirmed.
After operation, patient follow-up was arranged routinely once every 2 weeks in the first month and once every month thereafter, until 3 months after the fracture had healed. Then, follow-up every 6 months was arranged until 2 years after the operation. After that, annual follow-up was recommended. Therefore, all our patients would have monthly radiographic evaluations for the first 6–7 months.
Radiographic examinations, including posteroanterior and lateral views of the wrist and posteroanterior and oblique views of the hand, were performed at each follow-up, except the first follow-up for removal of the stitches. Evaluation of the radiographs was carried out by 2 independent observers who were blinded to the results. Fracture healing, the lateral SL angle, and the SL gap were evaluated and measured. The lateral SL angle generally ranged from 30° to 60°, and a widening of the SL gap of more than 3 mm was considered suspicious of SL dissociation . Computed tomography (CT) scan was not routinely performed, but only when fracture healing could not be confirmed. Functional outcomes, including wrist range of motion, the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) (0: no pain; 10: worst pain) during activity, and the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score , were evaluated at each follow-up after fracture healing was noted.
All collected data were examined using the SPSS software package (version 22; SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA). Functional evaluations data were presented as continuous response variables and were examined using the paired 2-tailed Student’s t-test for identification of improvement. The P-value was set at 0.05 before analysis.
Twenty-one patients who underwent proximal scaphoid nonunion treatment from 2008 to 2017, and who met the inclusion criteria, were enrolled (Table 1). The mean age was 31.8 years (range, 19–55 years). The mean duration from injury to surgery was 34.6 weeks (range, 24–43 weeks). The mean duration of the procedure was 143 min (range, 105–195 min). Nineteen patients achieved fracture healing and their mean follow-up period was 31.3 months (range, 24–120 months). No patients had obvious SL dissociation that was noted during the arthroscopy procedure. Nineteen patients achieved fracture healing, with a mean healing time of 16.3 weeks (range, 10–28 weeks). There were no perioperative complications. The 2 patients who developed nonunion after the index procedure were then lost to follow-up, and their last follow-up at around postoperative 1 year showed a VAS pain score of 5 during activity for both patients.
Four patients were noted to have vascular compromise of the scaphoid in the MRI and obvious sclerotic density of the proximal fragment in the radiographs. The 2 patients that failed to heal were among these 4 patients.
In the final follow-ups with a mean of 31.3 months (range, 24–120 months), patients with fracture healing showed improvement in wrist flexion (from 54.5o to 67.4o), wrist extension (from 62.3o to 71.7o), DASH score (from 52.4 to 21.4), VAS during activity (from 4.6 to 2.1), and grip strength (from 9.6 kg to 24.7 kg), with statistical significance (Table 2), and were able to return to their previous activities with no or mild pain; no wrist braces were required.
The lateral SL angle was statistically significantly improved from a mean of 82° (range, 60o to 99o) preoperatively, to 66o (range, 53o to 75o) postoperatively (p < 0.001). Seventeen patients requested screw removal after fracture healing. Most screw removal surgeries were performed 6–12 months after the index procedure under general anesthesia. After screw removal, a removable wrist orthosis was used for patient comfort, but was not routinely applied. Patients were allowed return to their previous work/activities one month after screw removal. The mean SL gap of the 17 patients was 2.2 mm at the time of screw removal, and 2.3 mm in the final follow-up, with a mean interval of 23.6 months (range, 12–112 months). The difference was not significant.
Arthroscopic-assisted bone grafting and SL screw transfixation for the treatment of proximal scaphoid nonunion yielded fracture healing in 19 of 21 patients (90.5%) in this study. These results are encouraging when compared to those of the open bone-grafting method for proximal scaphoid nonunion, in which fracture healing ranged from 90 to 100% [14, 25, 26]. Also, the healing time for our patients, at a mean of 16.3 weeks, was acceptable compared to that for proximal nonunion after open autologous bone grafting, which was reported to be 11.5–17.7 weeks [14, 15, 27].
There could be some intraarticular pathologies coexisting with a scaphoid nonunion. It has been reported in the literature that this constellation is perhaps not uncommon, and if present, the severity of the ligamentous injury is low [6, 28, 29]. With healing rates comparable to open methods, arthroscopic management has the advantages of providing a thorough wrist assessment, a comprehensive approach to address coexisting intraarticular pathologies, and minimal surgical trauma to the structure and vascularity, which is favorable for fracture healing [28, 30].
In treating chronic SL dissociation, RASL could be a treatment option [9, 18]. But in cases of scaphoid nonunion, the SLIL injury would most likely be minor. In our series, we did not see cases with obvious SL dissociation. Also, we did not denudate the SL junctional cartilage, as in the proposed RASL method [17, 18], but performed SL transfixation only. In the follow-ups of the 17 screw-removed patients, we found no further SL separation. So, it seems that screw fixation across the SL joint in proximal scaphoid nonunion treatment would not be harmful to the SL joint. But, as to the benefits for a probable concomitant SL injury after SL fixation, we still cannot draw a clear conclusion.
Rancy et al. reported that the proximal pole of the scaphoid would very likely have impaired vascularity in a fracture nonunion condition, but proximal scaphoid infarction is decidedly rare . The key surgical method is to perform a thorough debriding of the nonunion site and non-vascularized autologous bone grafting. Rancy et al. reported an overall healing rate of 97.1% in treating 35 scaphoid nonunions. However, some surgeons prefer the use of vascularized bone graft, due to the accepted advantages of improved circulation and an enhanced bone healing process [10, 11, 31].
In our study, 2 of the 4 patients who had both vascular compromise of the scaphoid in the MRI and obvious sclerotic density in the radiographs failed to heal. This failure rate is considerable when using this arthroscopy-assisted method for proximal scaphoid nonunion with obvious vascular compromise, although the case number was small. But, in our opinion, if surgeons are familiar with arthroscopic treatment, this method is a minimally invasive surgery that is still worthy of being performed in this patient group, and would not hinder further surgeries too much, even if it fails. However, detailed communication with the patient prior to surgery is necessary and important.
Use of the exaggerated dumbbell-shaped screw in the RASL procedure is suggested (Fig. 2), since a thin part of the screw shaft located at the SL junction seems able to prevent screw loosening; however, the evidence is still inconclusive [17, 18]. We used conical screws in only 3 cases, and they all had fracture healing (Fig. 3). Because of the small number of cases, we cannot conclude that a conical screw could achieve healing success similar to that of a dumbbell-shaped Herbert-like screw for SL transfixation in proximal scaphoid nonunion treatment.
SL screw removal is not routinely suggested if there is no loosening . However, the majority of our patients requested SL screw removal, and this was performed at least 6 months after fixation. This is because, in our culture, people prefer not to leave hardware in the body, if possible. Although we did not encounter complications with screw removal, we do agree that screw removal should be performed only when there is loosening or symptoms related to the screw.
We believe that the use of K-wires instead of the headless screw for SL transfixation would also be a good choice. In our results, the mean fracture healing time was 16.3 weeks. Thus, the fracture healing period with this arthroscopic treatment would not be too long. In addition, K-wires are easier to remove. As their diameter is small, K-wires could possibly be placed with less morbidity than a larger-sized headless screw. However, K-wires could possibly cause skin irritation.
Radial styloidectomy is an acceptable method for treating stage 1 SNAC, but we performed it in only 1 case (case 13). Whether radial styloidectomy will interfere with the results is still unclear. But, according to the study by Vutescu et al., radial styloidectomy should be performed with caution in cases with proximal pole scaphoid nonunion. Their results showed removal of part of the degenerated radial styloid could endanger the carpal extrinsic ligaments and cause carpal instability .
There were some limitations in this study, including its retrospective nature and the small number of cases. The majority of enrolled cases were female, which is not consistent with the reported epidemiology [34, 35]. This is because in the early enrollment period, male patients were still mainly treated with either the open vascularized or non-vascularized bone grafting method. Young female patients would often request treatment due to cosmetic concerns, so the arthroscopic method was performed more with them. Fracture healing was evaluated mainly with radiographs, which are not as precise as a CT scan. Also, the differences in patient characteristics and treatment, such as the use of different types of screws, the differences in the length of follow-up, and operations performed by 2 different surgeons, could also bias this study. The majority of our patients had screw removal, and this would be a drawback of the technique, in that the results would mainly show that the technique included temporary screw fixation across the SL joint for proximal pole scaphoid nonunion.
For proximal scaphoid nonunion, arthroscopic-assisted reduction, bone grafting and screw fixation across the SL joint could be an alternative treatment if the surgeon is familiar with arthroscopic procedures. A good healing rate and functional outcomes could be achieved. However, further comparative studies are still needed.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Arthroscopic reduction-association of the scapholunate
the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand
Dorsal intercalated segmental instability
Headless Compression Screw
Magnetic resonance imaging
Scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse
Scapholunate interosseous ligament
Visual Analog Scale
Lee SK, Park J, Baskies M, Forman R, Yildirim G, Walker P. Differential strain of the axially loaded scapholunate interosseus ligament. J Hand Surg Am. 2010;35(2):245–51.
Kawamura K, Chung KC. Treatment of scaphoid fractures and nonunions. J Hand Surg Am. 2008;33(6):988–97.
Pinder RM, Brkljac M, Rix L, Muir L, Brewster M. Treatment of scaphoid nonunion: a systematic review of the existing evidence. J Hand Surg Am. 2015;40(9):1797–805.
de Roo MGA, Dobbe JGG, van der Horst CMAM, Streekstra GJ, Strackee SD. Carpal kinematic changes after scaphoid nonunion: an in vivo study with four-dimensional CT imaging. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2019;44(10):1056–64.
Mack GR, Bosse MJ, Gelberman RH, Yu E. The natural history of scaphoid non-union. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1984;66(4):504–9.
Kang HJ, Chun YM, Koh IH, Park JH, Choi YR. Is arthroscopic bone graft and fixation for scaphoid nonunions effective? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2016;474(1):204–12.
Fernandez DL, Eggli S. Non-union of the scaphoid. Revascularization of the proximal pole with implantation of a vascular bundle and bone-grafting. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1995;77(6):883–93.
Trumble T, Nyland W. Scaphoid nonunions. Pitfalls and pearls. Hand Clin. 2001;17(4):611–24.
Gaspar MP, Kane PM, Jacoby SM, Culp RW. Novel treatment of a scapholunate ligament injury with proximal pole scaphoid nonunion. J Hand Microsurg. 2016;8(1):52–6.
Malizos KN, Dailiana ZH, Varitimidis SE, Papatheodorou L. Scaphoid reconstruction with vascularized bone grafts from the distal radius. J Hand Microsurg. 2009;1(1):50–3.
Malizos KN, Dailiana Z, Varitimidis S, Koutalos A. Management of scaphoid nonunions with vascularized bone grafts from the distal radius: mid- to long-term follow-up. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2017;27(1):33–9.
Burger HK, Windhofer C, Gaggl AJ, Higgins JP. Vascularized medial femoral trochlea osteocartilaginous flap reconstruction of proximal pole scaphoid nonunions. J Hand Surg Am. 2013;38(4):690–700.
Lim TK, Kim HK, Koh KH, Lee HI, Woo SJ, Park MJ. Treatment of avascular proximal pole scaphoid nonunions with vascularized distal radius bone grafting. J Hand Surg Am. 2013;38(10):1906–12.
Luchetti TJ, Rao AJ, Fernandez JJ, Cohen MS, Wysocki RW. Fixation of proximal pole scaphoid nonunion with non-vascularized cancellous autograft. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2018;43(1):66–72.
Matsuki H, Ishikawa J, Iwasaki N, Uchiyama S, Minami A, Kato H. Non-vascularized bone graft with Herbert-type screw fixation for proximal pole scaphoid nonunion. J Orthop Sci. 2011;16(6):749–55.
Megerle K, Keutgen X, Muller M, Germann G, Sauerbier M. Treatment of scaphoid non-unions of the proximal third with conventional bone grafting and mini-Herbert screws: an analysis of clinical and radiological results. J Hand Surg Eur. 2008;33(2):179–85.
Rosenwasser MP, Miyasajsa KC, Strauch RJ. The RASL procedure: reduction and association of the scaphoid and lunate using the Herbert screw. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg. 1997;1(4):263–72.
Aviles AJ, Lee SK, Hausman MR. Arthroscopic reduction-association of the scapholunate. Arthroscopy. 2007;23(1):105.e1–5.
Slade JF 3rd, Dodds SD. Minimally invasive management of scaphoid nonunions. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006;445:108–19.
Tang JB, Giddins G. Why and how to report surgeons’ level of expertise. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2016;41(4):365–6.
Schernberg F, Elzein F. Fracture types and fragment dislocations of the scaphoid bone of the hand. Handchir Mikrochir Plast Chir. 1987;19(2):59–66.
Watson HK, Ballet FL. The SLAC wrist: scapholunate advanced collapse pattern of degenerative arthritis. J Hand Surg Am. 1984;9(3):358–65.
Schimmerl-Metz SM, Metz VM, Totterman SM, Mann FA, Gilula LA. Radiologic measurement of the scapholunate joint: implications of biologic variation in scapholunate joint morphology. J Hand Surg. 1999;24(6):1237–44.
Hudak PL, Amadio PC, Bombardier C. Development of an upper extremity outcome measure: the DASH (disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand) [corrected]. The upper extremity collaborative group (UECG). Am J Ind Med. 1996;29(6):602–8.
DeMaagd RL, Engber WD. Retrograde Herbert screw fixation for treatment of proximal pole scaphoid nonunions. J Hand Surg Am. 1989;14(6):996–1003.
Stark HH, Rickard TA, Zemel NP, Ashworth CR. Treatment of ununited fractures of the scaphoid by iliac bone grafts and Kirschner-wire fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1988;70(7):982–91.
Rancy SK, Swanstrom MM, DiCarlo EF, Sneag DB, Lee SK, Wolfe SW. Success of scaphoid nonunion surgery is independent of proximal pole vascularity. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2018;43(1):32–40.
Lee YK, Choi KW, Woo SH, Ho PC, Lee M. The clinical result of arthroscopic bone grafting and percutaneous K-wires fixation for management of scaphoid nonunions. Medicine (Baltimore). 2018;97(13):e9987.
Kang HJ, Chun YM, Oh WT, Koh IH, Lee SY, Choi YR. The effect of debridement of coexisting partial ligament injuries on outcomes following arthroscopic osteosynthesis for minimally displaced scaphoid nonunions. J Hand Surg Am. 2016;41(6):e135–42.
Darlis NA, Weiser RW, Sotereanos DG. Partial scapholunate ligament injuries treated with arthroscopic debridement and thermal shrinkage. J Hand Surg Am. 2005;30(5):908–14.
Alluri RK, Yin C, Iorio ML, Leland H, Mack WJ, Patel K. A critical appraisal of vascularized bone grafting for scaphoid nonunion. J Wrist Surg. 2017;6(3):251–7.
Koehler SM, Guerra SM, Kim JM, Sakamoto S, Lovy AJ, Hausman MR. Outcome of arthroscopic reduction association of the scapholunate joint. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2016;41(1):48–55.
Vutescu ES, Jethanandani R, Sneag DB, Wolfe SW, Lee SK. Radial styloidectomy for scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse - relevance of nonunion location. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2018;43(1):80–3.
Buijze GA, Ochtman L, Ring D. Management of scaphoid nonunion. J Hand Surg Am. 2012;37(5):1095–100.
Moran SL. Current concepts and controversies in scaphoid fracture management. Hand Clin. 2019;35(3):xiii.
We thank Fang-Chun Kuo from Chiayi Christian Hospital for the original artwork in Fig. 1, illustrating the surgical technique.
This work was supported in part by grants from Taipei Veterans General Hospital (V107C-108), and the Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST 106–2314-B-075-060). We were assisted in part by the Division of Experimental Surgery of the Department of Surgery, Taipei Veterans General Hospital.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Taipei Veterans General Hospital, Taiwan. (IRB number: 2018–08-010 AC). Written consent was obtained from all patients who participated in this study.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, JP., Huang, HK. & Shih, JT. Arthroscopic-assisted reduction, bone grafting and screw fixation across the scapholunate joint for proximal pole scaphoid nonunion. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 21, 834 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-020-03850-w
- Bone transplantation
- Scaphoid bone