- Research article
- Open Access
Solitary bone cyst: a comparison of treatment options with special reference to their long-term outcome
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders volume 17, Article number: 162 (2016)
Solitary bone cysts (SBC) are benign, tumor-like lesions, which most frequently occur in the proximal metaphyseal-diaphyseal region of the humerus and femur of children and adolescents. The lack of a clear pathoetiology has impeded the development of treatment strategies. Up to date there is no consensus or official guideline for when and how treat SBC. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness and the longterm clinical outcome of the treatment of SBC. Different techniques have been used dependant of the site of lesion, dimension, medical history and activity status.
135 skeletal immature patients with a solitary bone cyst were included. A follow up of 36 months or more was available for all patients. 22 patients were treated conservatively. All the other patients had at least one surgical intervention. The following four surgical treatment modalities were used: injection of methylprednisolon acetat (steroids), intramedullary nailing (IN), IN + steroids and curettage plus bone grafting.
There was no significant difference between the treatment groups with respect to secondary fractures, function, pain, or complications. In the individual groups the failure rate after initial treatment was 36,6 % with steroids, 50 % with intramedullary nailing, 21,4 % with intramedullary nailing plus steroids and none in the remaining group.
Steroid injection remains a reliable method for treating solitary bone cysts owing to its low invasiveness. To prevent fractures and allow a full weight bearing, internal fixation in combination with methylprednisolon acetat injections seems to be the most favorable in weight bearing bones.
Solitary bone cysts (SBC) also known as unicameral bone cysts (UBC) are benign, fluid-filled, single chambered tumor-like lesions. They most commonly occur in the proximal metaphyseal-diaphyseal region of the humerus and femur of children and adolescents. The absolute incidence is unknown, it is estimated that approximately 3 % of all bone tumors are SBC . Since SBC show specific radiographic features on plain x-ray further imaging studies are usually not required, especially in long bones. The classic appearance is a centrally located, radiolucent, well-marginated, slightly expansile lesion of the proximal metaphysis. The growth plate is normally not affected by these expansive cysts. The cortex of the bone have a tendency to get thin and weak. This thinned cortex is an area of structural weakness and is prone for a pathological fracture. The ‘fallen leave’ sign is indicative for SBC . The cyst is often asymptomatic, but pain in the affected region may be present. Often the first and only symptom is a pathological fracture following a trivial trauma [2, 3], but sometimes the initial diagnosis is made after a radiological investigation performed for other reasons.
Since the first documentation of SBC by the German pathologist Rudolph Virchow in 1876 , the cause remains unspecified. Therefore the evolution of a conclusive treatment targeting the source is still missing. Numerous hypotheses have been proposed to explain the pathogenesis of SBC, e.g. bone resorptive properties of the cyst lining, vascular obstruction, increase in intracavitary osseous pressure,inflammation or traumatic causes [5–10].
There is a wide selection of options to handle SBCs, including observation, decompression of the cyst (using cannulated screws or nails) instillation of bone marrow, steroids or demineralized bone matrix, mechanical disruption of the cyst (usually by curettage), structural support (e.g. flexible intramedullary nails or bone grafting) or combined approaches that address the lesion on multiple levels.
The objective of therapy is to prevent a pathologic fracture or re-fracture, promote cyst healing, and to avoid cyst recurrence. The purpose of this study was to assess the healing rates of SBC after different therapy modalities as well as the long term clinical outcome after treatment.
The patient archive at Olgahospital Stuttgart was searched to identify all skeletal immature patients treated for SBC between 2000 and 2010. We found 164 patients (112 boys and 52 girls) who were diagnosed and treated with a SBC. The inclusion criterions for this study were: a solitary bone cyst (diagnosed by histological or radiological features) and follow up for at least 3 years or Neer classification I and skeletal maturity . 29 patients were excluded, because of insufficient long-term clinical information (follow-up <3 years) or lost to follow-up. 22 patients had been managed conservatively (e.g. splint, cast), because the probability of healing was considered very high (n = 18), or the consent for an operation was denied. All the other patients (n = 113) had at least one kind of surgical intervention. The patient demographics are shown in Table 1.
All procedures were performed under general anaesthesia. Surgical procedures were the following:
aspiration and injection with methylprednisolone (group I),
elastic stable intramedullary nailing (group II),
a combination of the above (group III),
curettage followed by bone grafting with an autograft or allograft (group IV).
We used the technique of Scaglietti . in a modified manner. A 11-gauge aspiration needle was inserted percutaneously to aspirate the contents of the cyst. 80 to 160 mg of methylprednisolone-acetat was inserted into the cyst. The dose of steroid ranged depending on cyst size. The patient was discharged on the same day, after the injection,. This procedure was performed three times with an interval of four to six weeks between every injection. Pathological fractures were allowed to heal for six weeks before the treatment with steroids was started. All patients treated with steroids as a primary intervention received exactly 3 injections.
For intramedullary nailing we followed the classical surgical technique, as reported by Ligier et al.  using a retrograde nailing approach. In case of a pathological fracture, first the closed reduction of the fracture was performed. Under fluoroscopic guidance the elastic intramedullary nailing (in an ascending manner) was completed. The diameter of the nails (2.0 to 3.0 mm) was selected on the basis of the anterior-posterior radiograph and intraoperative findings according to the principles described earlier . Same setup was used in the case of prophylactic intramedullary nailing.
Utilizing a standard approach to the different locations of the cyst, the cortex above the lesion was opened by four to six drill holes thru the cortex and using a chisel to connect the holes and remove the bony window. After the fluid was removed, the membrane of the cyst was rigorous curetted. To monitor the procedure the fluoroscope was used to assure that the curettage reached the outside of the SBC.
For bone grafting either autologous bone from the iliac crest or allogenic bone (Phoenix®, TBF, France) was used and the complete cyst was packed.
Postoperative treatment and radiological control
Postoperative treatment was aligned to the specific findings of the lesion. The therapy varied upon the site and location, size and volume, presence of fracture and displacement etc. Thus treatment (not only postoperative) ranged from simple dressings and splints to cast therapy and activity and weight bearing restrictions.
Radiographs were taken six and 12 weeks after surgery and from then on every six months. Controlled by improvement or recurrence the radiological monitoring was individually modified. All radiographs taken during the course of treatment were analyzed and the cyst volume was calculated (length by width by depth in cubic centimeters based on two orthogonal plain radiographs). SBCs are classified into active or latent according to Jaffe and Lichtenstein . When the distance to the physis was less than 10 mm the cyst was classified as an active cyst. All cyst showing more tan 10 mm distance from the physis were classified as latent.
Measuring the volume of the cyst is an attempt to quantify the SBC, but normally the volume is not matched to the size of the bone. One option is to match the volume to the diameter of the (normal part of the) shaft as it was proposed by Kaelin and MacEwen as “cyst index” .
The Neer/Cole rating system [2, 13] was used to monitor treatment response. The radiographic results were defined as I (healed) when complete obliteration of the cyst was shown. Grade II (residual defects) was defined new bone filled the lesion, but some opaque areas were still present. Grade III (cyst visible) was defined when multilocular and lucent residue areas were visible. Grade IV (cyst clearly visible) was assigned when the cyst was unchanged after the treatment. Grades I and II were considered as good results: cyst healed; grades III and IV were considered poor results: cyst not healed or pending pathological fracture.
The primary study outcome was the cyst-healing and the secondary outcome included the function and activity, pain, subsequent fractures, and complications. Pain that persisted at least 1 year after surgery was scored as a binary variable (present or absent). Physical activity was scored on a five-level response scale (1 not restricted in daily activity/playing – 5 substantial limited in daily activity/playing).
Do determine factors influencing the healing rate, the following parameters were included into the analysis:
Sex, Age, Site, Cyst volume, Cyst status, Cyst index and Fracture before initial treatment.
Analysis was conducted using SPSS software (version 15, SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). For the analysis of dichotomous variables between two groups, a chi-square cross tab test was performed. Values of p < 0.05 were considered significant. Recurrence rate was determined using the Kaplan-Meier method with treatments compared by the log rank test.
In 83 of 135 patients the diagnosis of SBC was confirmed by the pathologist. Since no material for histological examination was obtained in the 52 remaining patients the diagnosis based on the typical radiographic morphology. At presentation, 93 patients (68.9 %) had a pre-existing pathological fracture. In our patients pathological fractures significantly involved the humerus more often than the femur (p = 0.039). There was an equal distribution of fractures in both sex. 39 patients (28.9 %) complained of pain at the site of the lesion and in 3 patients the SBC was recognized accidentally, because an x-ray was done for other reasons.
The median follow-up time period for all patients was 57.2 (36 – 92) month. The cysts were mainly located in long bones (n = 122), most commonly in the humerus (n =59) and the femur (n = 49). The other locations in long bones were the tibia (n = 7), fibula (n = 5) and radius (n = 2). Nearly 90 % (109 of 122) of the lesions were located in the proximal part of the bone. Eight cysts were located in the calcaneus, three in the os pubis and two in the ilium.
The cyst volume found to be related to healing rate. If the cyst volume was > 84.3 cm3 the healing rate for the SBC was significantly reduced in comparison of all the groups (p < 0.03). Considered the individual group, there was no significant difference regarding the cysts size and the healing rate allocable. Size and pathological fracture was only dependent in long bones. From a size of 96.4 cm3, the probability of a pathological fracture was significantly increased (p < 0047). The volume tends to be bigger in the upper extremity compared to the lower extremity, but did not reached significance in our patients.
The cyst index at diagnosis showed a significant relation to the healing rate. The cyst index was similar in all different groups but showed differences among the locations (upper extremity average 5.6 (SD 1.8) and lower extremity average 4.8 (SD 1.3)). When the cyst index was correlated with the healing rate the reference values suggested by Kaelin  were used. In the upper and lower extremity a cyst index < 3.5 showed a significant lower failure rate than a cyst index > 5 - independent from the treatment groups.
Of the 135 patients, 74 had an active bone cyst at an age of 8.3 years and the other 61 had latent bone cysts at an age of 11.8 years. Patients with active cysts were significantly younger (p = < 0.01). In active cysts of long bones we recognized a higher failure rate. This was not significant between the different groups, nor the location in the upper or lower extremity. A list of a parameters included into the analysis is shown in Table 2.
The failure rate in the conservative group was 27.3 % (6 of 22). Overall recurrence rate after primary surgical therapy was 26.1 % (31/119) for all surgical procedures - recurrence being defined as requiring further surgical treatment (re-fracture, grade III/IV, limited function or ongoing pain). 19 patients from the conservative group (n = 5) and group I (n = 14) experienced a fracture after initial treatment. There were no significant associations between fractures and cyst activity, cyst area, loculation, location in the upper or lower extremity, or location within the bone. In the individual groups the failure rate after initial treatment was 36.6 % (15 of 41) with steroids, 50 % (4 of 8) with intramedullary nailing, 21.4 % (12 of 56) in the intramedullary nailing plus steroids and none in the curettage and bone graft group (see Table 3). The Kaplan-Meier analysis shows that further surgical treatment was required between 10–20 months after initial treatment (Fig. 1). Steroids and conservative treatment were associated with earlier failures than the other therapies. The failure rate was significantly higher in patients with an active bone cyst, independent from treatment and location (p < 0.03).
After the surgery occasional pain, numbness, or tingling was reported on the first visits (up to 6 month after last treatment), there was not significantly different among all the groups. Regarding the function there was also no difference between the treatment groups. Function was persistently very good in all the patients (not restricted in daily activity). We did not see a cyst recurrence after the cyst was completely healed (Neer Grade I). At the time the patient reached skeletal maturity the majority of the SBC were healed completely, only 22 % of the SBC were classified Grade II. Not one of the patients reached skeletal maturity with a cyst graded III or IV.
The first treatment choice was not successful in 37 patients, and all patients underwent an invasive intervention. Three out of the 37 patients needed a third operation. Five patients received a second course of steroid injection (3× injections). One out of these five needed a third intervention. In nine patients the IN had to be change, because the nails did not bridge the cyst. These cysts healed without any further treatment. 17 patients were retreated with intramedullary nailing plus steroids, in two patients the cyst failed to heal after this retreatment. In six patients a curettage and bone grafting was performed as second line treatment, all of them healed completely. In all patient (n = 3) where the second line treatment failed, a curettage with bone graft was performed.
Seven patients developed complications after invasive treatment; one patient was treated for a donor-site infection after autologous bone grafting. Three patients had a growth disturbance with a mild deformity of the shaft, and two patients showed a limb shortening with epiphyseal arrest. In one patient a femoral head necrosis was observed - in this boy the cyst did not respond to the steroid injection and no response was noted after intramedullary nailing, thus a curettage and bone grafting was performed. This is the only patient were the function was not restored completely 2.5 years after the last treatment. He still has some limitation walking long distances and running or jumping.
Whenever a child with a SBC is presented to a orthopedic surgeon the decision whether to observe or treat has to be made. There is no consensus or official guideline for when to treat a SBCs. If the decision is made to treat the child with a SBC the demanding questions is, how to treat. Currently, there is also no covenant on a reliable exemplary therapy. Up to date there is an only one multi-center randomized trial published, comparing intralesional steroid injection and bone marrow injection . The indications for an invasive treatment should consider prevention of pathologic fracture, reduction and stabilization of fractures, prevention of prolonged activity restriction and the consolidation of the cyst. In the literature some reliable methods to calculate the fracture risk are reported [14, 15]. Thus our aim was to share our therapy experience and help to identify reliable treatment for SBC.
Like the most retrospective studies this study has certain limitations, including inherent selection bias. Indications and treatment selection were based on clinical criteria and physician discretion rather than objective criteria. However, we believe the high number of patients analyzed compensate for any such inconsistencies. Nonetheless, our retrospective study of 135 patients with a SBC having an average follow-up of ~5 years is one of the largest in the literature. In our patients we had significantly more humerus than femur fractures. This finding is in concordance with previous studies [5, 16]. It is assumed that the lack of weight load in the humerus enable the cyst to grow unrecognized until the structural characteristics of the bone are limited and subsequent a pathological fracture occurs. Since the long bone of the lower extremity withstand a considerable weight load pain as a first symptome is recognized.long before a mechanical threat happens. The cyst index, which was increased in the humerus compared to the femur support this hypothesis too.
After a course of three consecutive intralesional injections of methylprednisolon acetat the failure rate was 36,6 % in our patients. In comparable trials the rate is between 32 and 24 % [3, 17, 18]. In a previous study from our institution including 71 patients with SBC the failure rate was similar ~30 % . Although Scaglietti et al.  have reported doses up to 240 mg, we are not aware of any dose–response curve that suggests higher doses are more effective. The study by Wright et al.  revealed that steroids are the only evidence based therapy.
To achieve higher rates of success with one single intervention, some authors advocated injection of bone marrow, together with multiple perforations of the cyst wall to re-establish the continuity between the cavity of the cyst and the adjacent normal marrow [8, 13]. This strategy makes it difficult to separate the effects of mechanical disruption from those produced by the osteogenic capacity of bone marrow injected into the cyst. In another report of 79 patients where steroid injections were compared with injection of bone marrow, no advantage of one or the other method could be shown . Referring to the only randomized prospective clinical trial steroid injection still showed a significantly better outcome than bone marrow .
The intramedullary nailing of long bones is not a new concept . Some studies reported and success rates between 75 and 100 % [21, 22]. Using this technique has the advantage of a minimal invasive procedure, immediately stability and continuous decompression. Since there is no further cortical impairment (as in e.g. curettage), hospital stay and return to normal activity are positively affected. Moreover, this technique can easily be combined with other procedures during one intervention, such as injection of steroids. The success rates in the presented study of 50 %, resp. 79.6 % are consistent with those reported in the literature. The relatively high failure rate of 50 % can be explained with the growth of the children. The nails did not bridge the cyst in 3 of 4 cases during the healing course, and an exchange of the intramedullary nails was necessary. This hypothesis is supported by the proportional late consequential operations. We did not find significant differences of the treatment according to the location (upper vs. lower extremity). In our experience the combination of intramedullary nailing and a course of steroid injection showed the best clinical result and is our preferred treatment option in the case of non obliteration of the cyst or in weight bearing long-bones.
Curettage and disruption of the cyst lining combined with bone grafting has been considered as the gold standard for many years . This procedure provides enough osteogenic stimulus to enhance healing [16, 23]. Nevertheless, there is a need for less invasive strategy, considering the benign and self-limited nature of the lesion . In a small study percutaneous curettage alone showed to be superior to intralesional injections and thus this approach was favored by the authors . Studies reporting the efficacy of bone substitutes are limited . Only few clinical studies are found in the literature. The recovery rates vary between 66 % up to 100 %. But most of these studies have a lack of follow-up >12 month after diagnosis . In our study, patients initially treated by curettage with a combined bone grafting (group IV) no recurrence was observed. We assume that these good results can be explained on the one hand by the location of the SBC and the mechanical stress and on the other hand to the age of the patient (>11 years).
In this study we were able to offer long-term clinical outcome for conservative and surgical treatment of SBC. Our results confirm the satisfactory overall long-term outcome. Focusing on short-and mid-term surveillance a substantial rate of recurrence for all different treatment strategies could be detected. Long-term follow up of more than 24 months is rarely conveyed in many other studies. We not only focused on the radiographic appearance, but also included, pain, function and re-fracture rates. Considering the assumed long-term success of SBC therapy, invasive strategies have to be carried out as cautious as possible. In one study with a 7 year follow-up the residual cyst persist into early adulthood, but no further fractures were detected even when the healing was graded III or IV .
We believe that the invasiveness of the procedure must be contrasted by the need for repeated treatment (e.g. steroids). These factors must be balanced against risk of fracture and probability of success rate. Small, non symptomatic and latent SBC (particular in the calcaneus or the pelvic bones) can be observed and if necessary, therapy with injection of steroids can be started. Since we did not have any fractures in our group III we recommend internal fixation and the injection of steroids in long bones with a mechanical load to reduce fracture rate and to expedite the recovery of the child. In the upper extremity the cyst volume, the cyst index and the activity level should be considered when making a recommendation. The treatment options of conservative versus steroids injection versus fracture fixation and steroids should be discussed with the patient and the parents.
Ethics and consent to participate
An institution approval for this investigation was granted and all investigations were conducted in conformity with ethical principles of research. Informed consent for evaluation and anonymized assessment was obtained from all patients before treatment was started. Since all data could be obtained without further treatment or monitoring procedures the ethical committee (University of Tuebingen, Germany) waived the approval, this procedure is in accordance with the European regulations and the requirements for observational studies in Germany.
Consent to publish
Availability of data and materials
All the data supporting your findings is contained within the manuscript.
solitary bone cysts
Cohen J. Etiology of simple bone cyst. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1970;52(7):1493–7.
Neer 2nd CS, Francis KC, Marcove RC, Terz J, Carbonara PN. Treatment of unicameral bone cyst. A follow-up study of one hundred seventy-five cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1966;48(4):731–45.
Campanacci M, Capanna R, Picci P. Unicameral and aneurysmal bone cysts. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1986;204:25–36.
Virchow R. Über die Bildung von Knochencysten. Monatsberichte der Königlich Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften. 1876; (Suppl):369–438.
Docquier PL, Delloye C. Treatment of simple bone cysts with aspiration and a single bone marrow injection. J Pediatr Orthop. 2003;23(6):766–73.
Donaldson S, Chundamala J, Yandow S, Wright JG. Treatment for unicameral bone cysts in long bones: an evidence based review. Orthop Rev (Pavia). 2010;2(1), e13.
Jaffe HLLL. Solitary unicameral bone cyst with emphasis on roentgen picture, the pathologic appearance, and the pathogenesis. Arch Surg. 1942;44:1004–25.
Komiya S, Minamitani K, Sasaguri Y, Hashimoto S, Morimatsu M, Inoue A. Simple bone cyst. Treatment by trepanation and studies on bone resorptive factors in cyst fluid with a theory of its pathogenesis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993;287:204–11.
Scaglietti O, Marchetti PG, Bartolozzi P. The effects of methylprednisolone acetate in the treatment of bone cysts. Results of three years follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1979;61-B(2):200–4.
Shindell R, Huurman WW, Lippiello L, Connolly JF. Prostaglandin levels in unicameral bone cysts treated by intralesional steroid injection. J Pediatr Orthop. 1989;9(5):516–9.
Ligier JN, Metaizeau JP, Prevot J. [Closed flexible medullary nailing in pediatric traumatology]. Chir Pediatr. 1983;24(6):383–5.
Kaelin AJ, MacEwen GD. Unicameral bone cysts. Natural history and the risk of fracture. Int Orthop. 1989;13(4):275–82.
Wright JG, Yandow S, Donaldson S, Marley L. A randomized clinical trial comparing intralesional bone marrow and steroid injections for simple bone cysts. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;90(4):722–30.
Snyder BD, Hauser-Kara DA, Hipp JA, Zurakowski D, Hecht AC, Gebhardt MC. Predicting fracture through benign skeletal lesions with quantitative computed tomography. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2006;88(1):55–70.
Leong NL, Anderson ME, Gebhardt MC, Snyder BD. Computed tomography-based structural analysis for predicting fracture risk in children with benign skeletal neoplasms: comparison of specificity with that of plain radiographs. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2010;92(9):1827–33.
Parsch K, Arnold P, Jani L, Knapp S. Juvenile bone cysts. Relative value and therapy results of cortisone injections. Orthopade. 1995;24(1):65–72.
Donaldson S, Wright JG. Recent developments in treatment for simple bone cysts. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2011;23(1):73–7.
Bovill DF, Skinner HB. Unicameral bone cysts. A comparison of treatment options. Orthop Rev. 1989;18(4):420–7.
Chang CH, Stanton RP, Glutting J. Unicameral bone cysts treated by injection of bone marrow or methylprednisolone. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2002;84(3):407–12.
Imhauser G. Management of juvenile bone cysts using intramedullary nailing? Z Orthop Ihre Grenzgeb. 1968;105(3):110–1.
Roposch A, Saraph V, Linhart WE. Flexible intramedullary nailing for the treatment of unicameral bone cysts in long bones. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82-A(10):1447–53.
Santori F, Ghera S, Castelli V. Treatment of solitary bone cysts with intramedullary nailing. Orthopedics. 1988;11(6):873–8.
Hagmann S, Eichhorn F, Moradi B, Gotterbarm T, Dreher T, Lehner B, Zeifang F. Mid- and long-term clinical results of surgical therapy in unicameral bone cysts. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2011;12:281.
Chigira M, Maehara S, Arita S, Udagawa E. The aetiology and treatment of simple bone cysts. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1983;65(5):633–7.
Canavese F, Wright JG, Cole WG, Hopyan S. Unicameral bone cysts: comparison of percutaneous curettage, steroid, and autologous bone marrow injections. J Pediatr Orthop. 2011;31(1):50–5.
Donaldson S, Wright JG. Simple bone cysts: better with age? J Pediatr Orthop. 2015;35(1):108–14.
This work was performed at the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Olgahospital, Klinikum Stuttgart, Bismarckstrasse 8, Stuttgart 70176, Germany.
No funds were received in support of this work.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests that are relevant to the work described in this article. No benefits in any form have been or will be received from any commercial party that is related directly or indirectly to this work.
FT: Conception and design, acquisition of data, analysis and interpretation of data, writing, review, and revision of the manuscript. OE: Analysis and interpretation of data, review, and/or revision of the manuscript. FF: Analysis and interpretation of data, review, and/or revision of the manuscript. TW: Conception and design, analysis and interpretation of data, review, and/or revision of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
About this article
Cite this article
Traub, F., Eberhardt, O., Fernandez, F.F. et al. Solitary bone cyst: a comparison of treatment options with special reference to their long-term outcome. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 17, 162 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-016-1012-0
- Bone Grafting
- Pathological Fracture
- Intramedullary Nailing
- Steroid Injection
- Skeletal Maturity