Natural course of intra-articular shifting bone marrow edema syndrome of the knee
© Aigner et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2008
Received: 25 October 2007
Accepted: 11 April 2008
Published: 11 April 2008
Intra-articular shift (migration) of bone marrow edema syndrome (BMES) is a very rare disease. Only a few cases have been reported thus far. The condition may cause the clinician to suspect an aggressive disease.
We reviewed eight patients (four women and four men) with unilateral BMES located in the knee. The patients were aged 39 to 56 years (mean, 49.2 years). In all patients, bone marrow edema (BME) initially observed on magnetic resonance imaging (MR imaging) shifted within the same joint, i.e. from the medial to the lateral femoral condyle or the adjacent bone. Seven patients were given conservative therapy, including limited weight-bearing, for a period of three weeks after the initial detection of BMES, whereas one patient underwent surgical core decompression twice.
MR imaging showed complete restitution in 6 cases and a small residual edema in one case. A final control MR could not be obtained for one patient, who had no pain. A further patient had an avascular necrosis of the contralateral hip after 16 months. Improvement on MR imaging was correlated with the clinical outcome in all cases. All patients became asymptomatic after a mean period of 9 months (6–11).
Intra-articular shifting BMES is a very rare condition. As the disease is self-limiting, conservative therapy may be recommended.
Bone marrow edema syndrome (BMES) is a common cause of severe bone and joint pain. The disease is usually self-limiting in nature and the symptoms resolve spontaneously over a period of 6, or occasionally 12 months. BMES primarily occurs in the femoral head, but also in the knee, foot, or less frequently at other locations. The patients complain of pain under stress and at rest, as well as a limited range of motion in the affected joint.
The exact pathogenesis of BMES remains unclear. Commonly discussed theories include thromboembolism, obstruction of arteriolar inflow or venous outflow, injury to the vessel wall secondary to vasculitis, altered lipid metabolism, and reduced fibrinolysis [1–4].
Bone marrow edema (BME) shows reduced signal intensity on T1-weighted MR images and increased signal intensity on T2-weighted MR images. No focal changes are identified and joint effusion is usually present . The radiographs are initially normal but patients may subsequently develop severe osteopenia.
BMES is known to migrate between different joints of the same limb or different limbs (migratory osteoporosis, migrating BMES) . However, to our knowledge, shifting of BMES between different compartments of the same joint has been previously reported only in a few cases [7–11]. The purpose of this retrospective study was to analyze the clinical course and MR images of this rare disease.
Eight patients (four women and four men) aged 39 to 56 years (mean, 49.2 years), with intra-articular migratory BMES, were investigated retrospectively. The patients were retrieved from a collective of 50 consecutively diagnosed cases of painful BMES of the knee treated conservatively and by surgery. On the routinely performed MR investigation three months after the initial diagnosis, the location of the BME in the knee was found to have shifted to a different part of the knee. Patients with avascular necrosis (AVN) in the knee and other joints, and osteochondritis dissecans in a demarcated bone area; patients with BME secondary to osteoarthritis, mechanical stress or trauma; and patients with algodystrophy and corticosteroid medication at initial presentation were excluded. The average duration of pain had been 10 weeks (range, 6 to 18 weeks). Six patients (two women and four men) performed light sports (about 1 hour per week; one played soccer, two played tennis and three played golf). No patient presented with a history of BME in other joints than the knee. One had undergone surgery (partial medial meniscectomy) in the affected knee two years previously.
The laboratory data of the eight patients revealed mild lipid disorders in three patients, hyperglycemia in two, and elevated liver function tests in a further three patients (see additional file 1). Apart from these, no major disorders were found in blood parameters. Three patients smoked (5–30 cigarettes/day) and three reported regular intake of alcohol. The average body mass index (BMI) was 27.9 ± 7.3 (19.5 to 38.2); two patients were obese (BMI 33.8 and 38.2).
Plain anteroposterior and lateral radiographs under weight-bearing were available for every patient. They were found to be normal in five patients whereas two showed mild radiographic signs of osteoporosis and one showed minimal narrowing of the joint space in the bones affected by BME. Two patients presented with a mild varus deformity (hip/ankle angle 3° and 4° varus) of the leg axis.
MR imaging, including T1-weighted and T2-weighted fat suppressed (short tau inversion recovery) sequences, was performed before therapy. MR imaging was repeated every 12 weeks (8–14 weeks) until the MR imaging pattern normalized and the patients had no pain.
Treatment after the initial MR study consisted of a series of five infusions with 20 μg iloprost (Ilomedin®, Schering AG, Germany) in off-label use and in an inpatient procedure in seven patients, accompanied by 3 weeks of partial weight-bearing. Iloprost is a vasoactive prostacyclin analogue which dilates arterioles and venules, reduces capillary permeability and inhibits platelet aggregation . One patient with BMES of the medial femoral condyle underwent core decompression of the affected condyle. Pain at rest and effort-induced pain were rated by the patients at each visit on a visual analogue scale (VAS) from 0 to 10 cm.
The patients continued the conservative therapy accompanied by reduction of their daily-life activities (seven patients), partial weight-bearing (two patients for a further 4 weeks), or intake of non-steroidal anti-phlogistic drugs (six patients) after the intra-articular migration of the BMES had been diagnosed. One patient with BMES in the medial femoral condyle underwent core decompression of the medial femoral condyle after BMES had been initially diagnosed; drilling of the lateral femoral condyle was performed 5 months after the first operation.
The severity of effort-induced pain (VAS) was reduced from 7.5 (2.0–10.0) at baseline to 5.9 (2.4–7.9) after 3 months and to 0.6 (0–0.9) after the final examination. Pain at rest (VAS) diminished from 3.9 (1.5–7.8) to 2.8 (1.4–6.0) after 3 months and to 0 at the final follow-up. In one patient with BMES in the knee, avascular necrosis of the contralateral hip was evident within 16 months, which is being treated conservatively until the present time. All active patients were able to return to the same level of sports as that prior to commencement of their symptoms.
In 1959 Curtiss and Kincaid  reported three cases of young women who developed transient demineralization of the hip during the third trimester of pregnancy. Wilson et al. coined the term BME in 1988 after the introduction of MR imaging. It is controversially discussed as to whether BMES reflects a distinct self-limiting disease, a kind of reflex sympathetic dystrophy, or an early reversible form of osteonecrosis [1, 10, 14–16]. However, avascular osteonecrosis and BME are known to occur in different populations, which would militate against a common etiology. On the other hand, one of our patients with BMES in the knee showed avascular necrosis in the femoral head, which indicates a relationship between the two entities.
BMES is usually associated with a spontaneous onset of pain in the absence of prior trauma. Physical findings are minimal and laboratory values are usually normal or non-specific. Clinical improvement usually occurs over a period of 6, or occasionally 12 months. Joints of the lower limbs are much more commonly affected than those of the upper limbs.
Therapy options are conservative treatment (reduction of weight-bearing, analgesic and anti-inflammatory medication) and surgical treatment (core decompression) . In our department we usually treat patients presenting with BMES with intravenous iloprost in combination with reduced weight-bearing, which appears to accelerate the natural course of the disease in many cases [16, 18–22].
Many patients experience recurrence of BME in other joints, usually on the contralateral side. The term 'regional migrating osteoporosis' or 'regional migrating BMES' has been used in these cases. To our knowledge, a shift of BME within the different compartments of the same joint has only been described in a few case reports. As in our cases, migratory BMES had a benign course and improvement on the MR images was correlated with the clinical outcome in all patients [7–11].
In studies focusing on the knees, BMES was initially present in one femoral condyle and shifted to the contralateral femoral condyle or the tibia within a period of 2 to 4 months. In theory, this condylar shift could be due to a compensatory mechanism whereby the patient shifts weight-bearing to the unaffected painless side of the knee. However, this theory is rejected by some authors . In a further study, BME in healthy volunteers with altered weight-bearing was less extensive in size and milder than that observed in our cases . In another study it was found that typical BME caused by mechanical stress was mild, and located in the subchondral area. It had a linear or wedge-shaped appearance, whereas idiopathic BMES is characterized by large areas being affected, and not being limited to the subchondral bone . Therefore, all three cases of BME with minimal degenerative changes in the joint and large edematous areas without limitation to the subchondral region were considered to be of primarily ischemic origin.
Finally, we observed normalization of the MR imaging pattern in all patients treated with conservative therapy alone, which would contradict a purely mechanical etiology of the BMES. While the presence of meniscal tears might lead to altered biomechanical loading, we do not believe this is responsible for the shift of edema since this kind of BME due to biomechanical stress would be limited to the subchondral bone. In addition, this situation would more likely explain a vertical shift, for instance from the medial femoral condyle to the medial tibial plateau, rather than a horizontal migration from medial to lateral.
Our patients did not show a subchondral linear abnormal signal pattern of this type, but had a large BME affecting at least 25% of the femoral condyle or the tibial plateau. Furthermore, no association was found between the size of BME and its migration. In those cases in which BME shifts to an adjacent quadrant, it appears that the origin is the primary affected quadrant. However, in cases of atypical migration (such as from proximal to distal or vice versa or diagonally), it is unclear whether the condition is a shifting or a new BME. The authors' thesis of the pathogenesis of intra-articular migratory BMES is a regional, diffuse, and therefore reversible ischemia of unknown origin affecting adjacent bones or parts of a bone. The non-simultaneous but consecutive affliction prolongs the total duration of pain than that seen in ordinary BMES. A progression to an AVN is not likely but cannot be entirely ruled out, depending on the extent of damage to the terminal vascular bed.
Intra-articular shifting (or migrating) BMES has also been reported in other joints of the lower limb. Fernandez-Canton  published 25 cases of BME in the foot with a one-year follow-up. Six of seven cases without complete restitution of the BME showed migration of BME to other bones that were initially normal, or to previously non-edematous areas of affected bones. Furthermore, the authors noted soft tissue edema in all 25 cases of BME of the foot, and joint effusion in 10 of 25 cases.
In addition, the diagnosis of BME migration may be suggested only after other causes of edema, such as avascular necrosis, subchondral insufficiency fracture, infection, and post-traumatic bone bruise, have been excluded. We continue to perform MR imaging studies every three months in patients whose symptoms do not abate under conservative therapy. Furthermore, we recommend early MR imaging diagnosis of other painful joints such as the hip, knee and ankle, especially on the contralateral side, to detect migrating BMES.
The vasoactive drug iloprost did not accelerate the course of the disease in patients with intra-articular shifting BMES as it does in non-shifting BMES [16, 18–22] nor did it prevent shifting within the joint. Nevertheless, we recommend conservative therapy with partial weight-bearing and the administration of non-steroidal analgesic drugs rather than core decompression in these cases.
Limitations of the present report are the small number of patients and the retrospective nature of the study, which is due to the fact that this entity is very rarely seen. Further investigations are needed for a more comprehensive understanding of this disease.
Intra-articular migration of a large BMES appears to be an aggressive phenomenon, but the disease has a benign course and is self-limiting in nature. We therefore recommend conservative therapy.
- Atsumi T, Kuroki Y: Role of impairment of blood supply of the femoral head in the pathogenesis of idiopathic osteonecrosis. Clin Orthop. 1992, 277: 22-30.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Glueck CJ, Freiberg R, Glueck HI, Henderson C, Welch M, Tracy T, Stroop D, Hamer T, Sosa F, Levy M: Hypofibrinolysis: a common, major cause of osteonecrosis. Am J Hematol. 1994, 45: 156-166. 10.1002/ajh.2830450212.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hofmann S, Engel A, Neuhold A, Leder K, Kramer J, Plenk H: Bone marrow oedema syndrome and transient osteoporosis of the hip. J Bone Joint Surg (Br). 1993, 75: 210-216.Google Scholar
- Veldhuizen PJ, Neff J, Murphey MD, Bodensteiner D, Skikne BS: Decreased fibrinolytic potential in patients with idiopathic avascular necrosis and transient osteoporosis of the hip. Am J Hematol. 1993, 44: 243-248. 10.1002/ajh.2830440405.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Van de Berg BE, Malghem JJ, Labaisse MA, Noel HM, Maldague BE: MR imaging of avascular necrosis and transient marrow edema of the femoral head. Radio Graphics. 1993, 13: 501-520.Google Scholar
- Banas W, Kaplan FS, Fallon MD, Haddad JG: Regional migratory osteoporosis. A case report and review of the literature. Clin Orthop. 1990, 250: 303-309.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fertakos RJ, Swayne LC, Colston WC: Three phase bone imaging in bone marrow edema of the knee. Clin Nucl Med. 1995, 20: 587-590.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gaeta M, Mazziotti S, Minutoli F, Vinci S, Blandino A: Migrating transient bone marrow edema syndrome of the knee: MRI findings in a new case. Eur Radiol. 2002, 12 (Suppl 3): S40-2. 10.1007/s003300100934.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Moosikasuwan JB, Miller TT, Math K, Schultz E: Shifting bone marrow edema of the knee. Skeletal Radiol. 2004, 33 (7): 380-385. 10.1007/s00256-004-0783-9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Parker RK, Ross GJ, Urso JA: Transient osteoporosis of the knee. Skeletal Radiol. 1997, 26: 306-309. 10.1007/s002560050241.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wambeek N, Munk PL, Lee MJ, Meek RN: Intra-articular regional migratory osteoporosis of the knee. Skeletal Radiol. 2000, 29: 97-100. 10.1007/s002560050018.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Grant SM, Goa KL: Iloprost – A review of its pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic properties, and therapeutic potential in peripheral vascular disease, myocardial ischaemia and extracorporal circulation procedures. Drugs. 1992, 43: 889-924. 10.2165/00003495-199243060-00008.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Curtiss PH, Kincaid WE: Transitory demineralization of the hip in pregnancy: a report of three cases. J Bone Joint Surg (Am). 1959, 41: 1327-1333.Google Scholar
- Boos S, Sigmund G, Huhle P, Nurbakhsch I: MR of transient osteoporosis. Primary diagnosis and follow-up after treatment. Fortschr Roentgenstr. 1993, 158 (3): 201-206.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Doury P: Bone marrow oedema, transient osteoporosis and algodystrophy. J Bone Joint Surg (Br). 1994, 76: 993-994.Google Scholar
- Petje G, Radler C, Aigner N, Kriegs-Au G, Ganger R, Grill F: Aseptic osteonecrosis in childhood: diagnosis and treatment. Orthopade. 2002, 31 (10): 1027-1036. 10.1007/s00132-002-0387-9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hofmann S, Kramer J, Vakil-Adli A, Aigner N, Breitenseher M: Painful bone marrow edema of the knee: differential diagnosis and therapy concepts. Orth Clin N Am. 2004, 35 (3): 321-333. 10.1016/j.ocl.2004.04.005.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Aigner N, Petje G, Steinböck G, Schneider W, Krasny C, Landsiedl F: Treatment of bone marrow edema of the talus with the prostacyclin analogue iloprost – an MRI-controlled investigation of a new method. J Bone Joint Surg (Br). 2001, 84: 1050-1052. 10.1302/0301-620X.84B7.13175.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Aigner N, Petje G, Schneider W, Meizer R, Wlk M, Knahr K, Landsiedl F: Bone marrow oedema syndrome of the femoral head: Comparison of therapy with the prostacycline-analogue iloprost and core decompression. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2005, 117 (4): 130-135. 10.1007/s00508-005-321-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Meizer R, Radda C, Stolz G, Kotsaris S, Petje G, Krasny C, Wlk M, Mayerhoefer M, Landsiedl F, Aigner N: MRI-controlled analysis of 104 patients with painful bone marrow edema of different joint localizations treated with the prostacyclin analogue iloprost. Wien Klin Wochenschr. 2005, 117 (7–8): 278-286. 10.1007/s00508-005-0326-y.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Petje G, Radler C, Aigner N, Manner H, Kriegs-Au G, Grill F: Pharmacological management of aseptic osteonecrosis in childhood. Expert Opin Pharmacother. 2004, 5 (7): 1455-1462. 10.1517/14656522.214.171.1245.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Petje G, Radler C, Aigner N, Walik N, Kriegs-Au GK, Grill F: Treatment of reflex sympathetic dystrophy in children using a prostacyclin analog: preliminary results. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2005, 433: 178-182. 10.1097/01.blo.0000151877.67386.45.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schweitzer ME, White LM: Does altered biomechanics cause marrow edema?. Radiology. 1996, 198: 851-853.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fernandez-Canton G, Casado O, Capelastegui A, Astigarrada E, Larena JA, Merino A: Bone marrow edema syndrome of the foot: one year follow-up with MR imaging. Skeletal Radiol. 2003, 32: 273-278.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2474/9/45/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.