Author | Age/Gender | Etiology | Surgical tec | Follow-up | Defect size | Harvest site | Preoperative HSS | Postoperative HSS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Güngör et al. [7] | 22/F 23/ | Impingement Impingement | SHD SHD | 14 months 12months | 2.7 cm2 3.6 cm2 | Knee Knee | 52 46 | 93 85 |
Burak et al. [3] | 15/F | DDH | SHD | 18 months | NR | Nonweight-bearing portion of femoral head | 55 | 90 |
Kilicoglu et al. [8] | 27/M | Sequelae of AVN | SHD | 8 years | NR | Knee | 55 | 96 |
Gagala et al. [9] | 34/M 20/M 43/M | Trauma sequelae Trauma sequelae Trauma sequelae | SHD SHD SHD | 80 months 62 months 24 months | NR NR NR | Knee Knee Knee | NR NR NR | 98 100 90 |
Hart et al. [10] | 28/M | Trauma sequelae | SHD | 6 months | 14 mm2 | Knee | 69 | 100 |
D'Lima et al. [13] | 15/M 21/M | Trauma sequelae Trauma sequelae | SHD SHD | 12 months 5 years | 20×5 mm 10 mm2 | Knee Nonweight-bearing portion of femoral head | NR NR | NR NR |
Won et asl. [14] | 31/M | Trauma sequelae | SHD | 12 months | 2.5×1 cm | Knee | NR | 82 |
Anthonissen et al. [15] | 20/M | Trauma sequelae | SHD | 2 years | 2×2.5 cm | Knee | NR | 82 |
Lee et al. [16] | 62/M | Trauma sequelae | SHD | 2 years | 2×2.3 cm | Nonweight-bearing portion of femoral head | NR | NR |
Soteranos et al. [17] | 32/M | Osteonecrosis | SHD | 66 months | NR | Nonweight-bearing portion of femoral head | 45 | 96 |
Kubo et al. [18] | 37/F | OCD | SHD | NR | 8.5 mm2 | Knee | NR | NR |
Louahem et al. [19] | 15/F 16/F | OCD OCD | SHD SHD | 4 years 18 months | 2 cm2 | Nonweight-bearing portion of femoral head Knee | 52 | 93 |
Emre et al. [20] | 22/M | LCPD | SHD | 3 years | 1.5 cm2 8×18 cm | Knee Knee | 46 43 | 85 96 |
Girard et al. [21] | 10 cases Mean age: 18 (15-21) | 6 LCPD, 4 MED | SHD | Mean 29.2 months (20-39) | 4.8 cm2 (3-9) | Nonweight-bearing portion of femoral head | 52.8 (35-74) | 79.5 (65-93) |