Skip to main content

Table 2 Effect size, and statistical power of the included studies

From: Characterization and critical appraisal of physiotherapy intervention research in Nigeria: a systematic review

Author

Intervention for outcome(tool) in condition

P-values

Effect size

Power (%)

Remark

Abass et al. [22]

Lumbar stabilization for PI in chronic LBP

0.236

0.082

48

X

Abdulahi et al. [23]

CIMT improving MF in stroke

 > 0.05*

0.348

46

X

Abdullahi et al. [24]

CIMT for motor impairment in stroke

0.166

0.37

28

X

Adeniyi et al. [25]

Exercise improving for SBP in Type 2 DM

0.030*

IN

 

-

Adeniyi et al. [26]

Exercise for pain in Type 2 DM

 < 0.05*

IN

 

-

Adepoju et al. [27]

Exercise improving balance in CP

0.339

0.57

58

X

Ahmed et al. [28]

Stabilization exercise & mzl energy tech for pain in low back pain

 < 0.001*

0.7385

59

X

Ajiboye et al. [29]

Exercise improving walking capacity in CHF (biventricular)

p < 0.05*

1.28

100

√

Akinola et al. [24]

Exercise improving GMF in spastic CP

0.001*

0.236

9

X

Akodu & Akindutire [30]

Exercise for sleep disturbance in LBP (NS)

0.030*

0.6

100

√

Akodu et al. [31]

Stabilization and pilate exercise for pain in LBP

0.001*

1.239

96

√

Aliyu et al. [32]

Exercise for pain in LBP (NS)

0.6

0.0078

85

√

Asogwa et al. [33]

Progressive resistance exercise for CD4 count in HIV patients

 < 0.001*

0.82

87

√

Aweto et al. [34]

Exercise for depression score in PL HIV

0.925

0.36

100

√

Aweto et al. [35]

Incentive spirometry for FVC in Type 2 DM

0.925

0.071

6

X

Aweto et al. [36]

Incentive spirometer for FEV in asthma

0.001*

0.441

73

X

Bello & Adeniyi [37]

Exercise for pain intensity (VASB) in LBP

0.020*

1.93

100

√

Bello et al. [38]

Manual therapy for FVC in lumbar radiculopathy

0.000*

0.26

46

X

Bolarinde et al. [39]

Exercise for PI in LBP

 < 0.001*

0.023

60

X

Danazumi et al. [40]

Integrated neuromuscular inhibition tech for pain in piriformis syndrome

 < 0.001*

5.433

100

√

Danazumi et al. [41]

Chain Exercise & kinesiotaping for pain in OA

0.011*

2.116

100

√

Ezema et al. [42]

Exercise for FBS in Type 2 DM

0.001*

0.59

100

√

Ezema et al. [43]

Exercise for SBP in PLHIV

<0.010

2.74

100

√

Ezema et al. [44]

Exercise for FBS in type 2 DM

 < 0.01*

-1.281

98

√

Fadupin & Akinola [45]

Exercise for FBS in Type 2 DM

< 0.05*

0.16

100

√

Fayehun et al. [46]

Walking prescription for HBA1c in Type 2 DM

0.015*

0.035

5

X

Habibu & Hanif [47]

Non-thermal US for breast engorgement

0.153

0.132

8

X

Ibrahim et al. [48]

Motor control exercise for pain in low back pain

 < 0.05

0.767

87

√

Idowu & Adeniyi [49]

Graded activity with monitoring for PI in LBP and Type 2 DM

 < 0.001*

1.94

99

√

Ige et al. [50]

Pulmonary rehab for FEV1 in COPD

 < 0.050*

2.518

100

√

Jegede et al. [51]

Exercise for WR in obese individuals

 < 0.001*

1.17

99

√

John et al. [52]

Exercise for SBP in PL HIV

0.001*

0.12

100

√

Johnson et al. [53]

McKenzie for PI in LBP

0.02*

1.18

79

X

Kaka et al. [54]

Exercise for VAS in NS-neck pain

0.001*

1.267

100

√

Lamina & Okoye [55]

Exercise for lipid profile in hypertension

0.001*

0.007

57

X

Lamina & Okoye [56]

Moderate intensity training for SBP in hypertension

0.001*

1.22

100

√

Lamina & Okoye [57]

Exercise for SBP in hypertension

0.001*

0.67

100

√

Lamina & Okoye [58]

Interval training program for SBP in hypertension

0.001*

0.27

100

√

Lamina et al. [59]

Shortwave for pain for pain in PID

 < 0.001*

1.746

99

√

Lamina et al. [60]

Exercise for SBP in hypertension

0.001*

1.04

100

√

Maduagwu et al. [61]

Exercise for QoL in HIV seropositive

0.917

0.023

6

X

Maduagwu et al. [62]

Exercise for CD4 cells on in HIV

0.002*

0.82

90

√

Maharaj & Nuhu [63]

Exercise for FBS in type 2 DM

0.002*

0.122

21

X

Maruf et al. [64]

Aerobic dance for lipid (LDL-C) IN HTN patients

 < 0.05

-0.092

79

X

Maruf et al. [65]

Exercise for BP in hypertension

0.075

0.39

74

X

Maruf et al. [66]

Exercise for SBP in hypertensive patients

0.001*

0.751

98

√

Mbada et al. [67]

McKenzie for DBEE in LBP

0.001*

0.27

100

√

Mbada et al. [68]

Exercise for FAB in LBP

0.154

0.076

9

X

Nweke et al. [69]

Aerobic exercise (Cycle ergometer) for HAND

 < 0.05*

0.261

20

X

Nweke et al. [70]

Aerobic exercise (Cycle ergometer) for QoL in HAND

0.001*

3.156

100

√

Odebiyi et al. [71]

Exercise and massage for QoL of cancer patient

0.001*

0.39

100

√

Odole & Ojo [72]

Telephone based therapy for PI on OA

0.001*

0.16

100

√

Odunaiya et al. [73]

Aerobic exercise for depression in HIV patients

 < 0.05*

2.091

100

√

Ogbutor et al. [74]

Exercise for SBP in pre-hypertensives

1.653

1.5

100

√

Ogwumike et al. [75]

2 Exercises for Adiposity in peri- and post-menopausal

0.05

0.959

23

X

Ojeniweh et al. [76]

Infrared for pain in low back pain

 > 0.05*

-0.173

9

X

Ojoawo & Olabode [77]

TOP and traction for NDI in cervical radiculopathy

0.889

0.125

42

X

Ojoawo et al. [78]

Cervical traction for pain in cervical radiculopathy

 < 0.05*

-1.218

98

√

Ojoawo et al. [79]

Exercise for PI in LBP

1.000

0.052

5

X

Ojoawo et al. [80]

US and massage for PI in LBP

0.001*

0.57

99

√

Ojoawo et al. [81]

TOP for PI in cervical radiculopathy

 < 0.05*

0.53

85

√

Ojoawo et al. [82]

VOP for RMDQ in chronic LBP

0.692

0.549

68

X

Ojoawo et al. [83]

Exercise for VAS in knee OA

 < 0.01*

0.386

87

√

Okonkwo et al. [84]

Balance training for balance in cognitively-impaired stroke patients

 < 0.05*

3.37

100

√

Okonkwo et al. [85]

TENS for PI in injection sciatic pain

0.001*

0.16

13

X

Olagbegi et al. [86]

Exercise for SQMS in OA

 > 0.05*

0.07

100

√

Olagbegi et al. [87]

Exercise for ADL in OA

 < 0.001*

0.737

100

√

Onigbinde et al. [88]

Wobble board exercises & dynamic balance for static balance in stroke patients

0.001*

1.213

63

X

Onigbinde et al. [89]

IQS for RMx in OA

0.001*

0.644

89

√

Onigbinde et al. [90]

SWD for VAS in OA

0.03*

0.747

42

X

Onuwe et al. [91]

Double modality for PP in MSK injuries

 < 0.05*

0.293

24

X

Onwunzo et al. [92]

Isometric strengthening exercise for pain in OA

 < 0.001*

-4.907

100

√

Sarafadeen et al. [93]

Stabilization exercise for pain in LBP

 < 0.001*

-4.207

100

√

Sokunbi et al. [94]

TENS for sleep quality in pregnant women

0.717

0.196

10

X

Tella et al. [95]

TENS for tactile acuity in LBP

 < 0.05*

0.352

15

X

Usman et al. [96]

Combination therapy for pain in OA

0.001*

0.34

100

√

  1. *: significant at α = 0.05; X: finding is probably not a reflection of true effect; √: finding is probably a reflection of true effect; IN Information not available, DM Diabetes mellitus, CP Cerebral palsy, CIMT Constraint-induced movement therapy, CHF Congestive heart failure, WR Weight reduction, LBP (NS) Low back pain (non-specific), SBP Systolic blood pressure, Type 2 DM Type 2 diabetes mellitus, (G) MF (Gross) motor function, CHF Chronic heart failure, (PL) HIV (People living with) Human Immuno-deficiency virus, FVC Forced vital capacity, VAS (B) Visual analogue scale (back), PI Pain intensity, FBS Fasting blood sugar, HBA1c Glycosylated hemoglobin, DBEE Dynamic back extensors endurance, COPD Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, QoL Quality of life, OA Osteoarthritis, DRPEE Dynamic Back Endurance Exercise, US Ultrasound, SQS Static quadriceps muscle strength, TOP Transverse Oscillatory pressure, ADL Activity of daily living, FAB Fear-Avoidance Beliefs IQS- isometric quadriceps strengthening, SWD Short wave diathermy, RM Repetitive maximum, RMDQ Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire, FPG TENS Transcutaneous electrical stimulation, PID Pelvic inflammatory disorder, HTN Hypertension, RCT Randomized controlled trial