Skip to main content

Table 3 Between group standard mean differences (SMDs)

From: Efficacy of non-surgical management and functional outcomes of partial ACL tears. A systematic review of randomised trials

 

MPTS

 

IKDC 2000

LKS

Pain (VAS)

Proprioception

CKS

Extension 60 degrees

Flexion 60 degrees

Extension 180 degrees

Flexion 180 degrees

Buyukturan et al. [27]

Baseline

-0.05 [-0.56, 0.47]

-0.30 [-0.82, 0.22]

-0.15 [-0.67, 0.36]

0.39 [-0.13, 0.91]

 

-0.67 [-1.20, -0.14]

0.34 [-0.18, 0.86]

-0.18 [-0.69, 0.34]

0.38 [-0.14, 0.90]

Follow up

0.25 [-0.26, 0.77]

-0.10 [-0.61 0.42]

-2.17 [-2.83, -1.52]

-1.33 [-1.90, -0.75]

 

0.56 [0.04, 1.09]

0.51 [-0.02, 1.03]

1.32 [0.75, 1.89]

0.55 [0.03, 1.08]

Celik et al. [28]

Baseline

 

0.36 [-0.92, 0.20]

  

-0.10 [-0.65, 0.46]

  

-0.19 [-0.74, 0.37]

-0.03 [-0.59, 0.52]

Follow up

 

-0.29 [-0.84, 0.27]

  

0.37 [-0.19, 0.93]

  

0.63 [0.06, 1.20]

0.35 [-0.21, 0.90]

  1. Reported as Standard Mean Difference [95% confidence interval]
  2. IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee Questionnaire, LKS Lysholm Knee Scale, VAS Visual Analogue Scale, CKS Cincinnati Knee Scale, MPTS Muscle Peak Torque Strength