Table 5 Comparison of results with previous studies
From: Surgical outcomes of transverse acetabular fractures and risk factors for poor outcomes
Author | Age | Enrolled type of acetabular fracture | Number | Satisfactory reduction | OA | THA conversion | Poor outcome setting | Risk factors for poor outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mears et al. [5] | 46.5 | All types | 424 | 372 (88%) | 98 (23%) | 48 (11%) | Low Harris hip score | N/A |
Dunet et al. [16] | 41.6 | All types | 72 | N/A | 29 (40%) | 25 (35%) | Unsatisfactory MDP | Overweight, road accident, posterior wall fracture, initial intraarticular foreign body, unsatisfactory reduction |
Meena et al. [7] | 38.8 | All types | 118 | 110 (93%) | 34 (29%) | 10 (9%) | Unsatisfactory MDP | Femoral head dislocation, initial displacement (> 20 mm), associated injury, delay in surgery (> 14 days) |
Frietman et al. [10] | 48.5 | All types | 220 | 125 (57%) | 55 (25%) | 33 (15%) | THA conversion | Old age, marginal impaction, extended iliofemoral approach, unsatisfactory reduction |
Verbeek et al. [9] | 51.2 | All types | 227 | N/A | N/A | 55 (24%) | THA conversion | Age ≥ 50 yr, gap ≥5 mm, step ≥1 mm in young patients |
Oh et al. [6] | 46.6 | Tr ± PW | 15 | 11 (69%) | 2 (27%) | N/A | Unsatisfactory MDP | Gap > 2 mm, dome comminution, femoral head cartilage injury |
Li et al. [15] | 34.0 | Transtectal Tr | 37 | 35 (95%) | N/A | N/A | Unsatisfactory MDP | Acetabular roof comminution |
Masse et al. [12] | 35.3 | Tr ± PW or T | 31 | 25 (81%) | 4 (13%) | 4 (13%) | N/A | N/A |
Fahmy et al. [14] | 31.0 | Tr ± PW | 30 | 30 (100%) | 3 (10%) | N/A | N/A | N/A |
Current study | 41.7 | Tr ± PW and/or T | 39 | 29 (74.4%) | 11 (28.2%) | 5 (12.8%) | OA ± ONFH THA conversion | Residual gap, dome impaction |