Table 2 Clinical outcome scores reported in the included studies
Study | Arthroscopic Outcome | Open Outcomes | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
Cunningham G, 2016 [10] | Walch Duplay score − 88. Persistant apprehension - 4(5.5%) | Walch Duplay score − 91. Persistant apprehension - 0(0.0%) | Walch Duplay score - no significant difference |
Marion B, 2017 [13] | VAS (1 week) - 1.2 +/−1.4 WOSI (2 years) - 372.1+/− 140.9 | VAS (1 week) - 2.5+/− 1.4 WOSI (2 years) - 451+/− 158.7 | VAS p = .002 WOSI p = 0.03 |
Kordasiewicz B, 2017 [16] | Walch - Duplay score - 76.7 Rowe - 78.9 VAS- 1.38 Satisfaction% - 91.9 Residual subjective apprehension - 31% | Walch - Duplay score - 83.9 Rowe - 87.8 VAS- 0.77 Satisfaction% - 96.8 Residual subjective apprehension 28.7% | p < 0.05 for Rowe and Subjective apprehension only. The rest did not reach statistical significance. |
Metais P, 2016 [15] | Walch - Duplay score – 92.8. Rowe − 93.4 | Walch - Duplay score - 85.9. Rowe − 83.9 | Walch-Duplay score p < 0.0001 Rowe p < 0.0001 |
Nourissat G, 2016 [14] | VAS (30 days) - 1.2 | VAS (30 days) - 1.6 | VAS (30 days) p = 0.14 (note significantly lower VAS scores were found in arthroscopic group at earlier follow-ups). WOSI (6 months) - open had significantly better symptoms and sports/recreation/work scores than the arthroscopy group. No significant difference in Lifestyle and Emotion scores. |
Zhu Y, 2017 [17] | ASES- 93.3+/− 9.9 Constant Murley Socre - 96.5+/− 3.8 Rowe - 97.1+/− 2.5 | ASES- 93.0+/− 5.0 Constant Murley Socre - 95.0+/− 4.1 Rowe - 95.4+/− 5.0 | ASES p = .917 Constant-Murley p = .223 Rowe p = .181 |