Skip to main content

Table 4 Overview of relevant randomized controlled trial regarding Oral and IA administration of TXA compared with placebo in total knee arthroplasty

From: Comparison of oral versus intra-articular tranexamic acid in enhanced-recovery primary total knee arthroplasty without tourniquet application: a randomized controlled trial

Authors

Year

Dosing regimens

No. of patients

Reduced blood loss

Reduction of Hb

Increased complications

Reduced transfusion

   

TXA

Control

    

Oral administration

 Zohar et al.

2004

1 g oral TXA before surgery, 6 h, 12 h, and 18 h

20

20

Significant

NA

NS

Significant

 Charoencholvanich et al.

2011

10 mg/kg before deflation; 0.5 g oral TXA for 5 days

50

50

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Alipour et al.

2013

1 g oral TXA before surgery, 6 h, 12 h, and 18 h

26

27

Significant

NA

NS

NA

 Lee et al.

2017

1 g oral TXA 2 h before surgery, 6 and 12 h

95

95

Significant

Significant

NS

NA

 Yuan et al.

2017

20 mg/kg oral TXA 2 h before surgery; 2 g oral TXA 12 h postoperatively

140

140

NA

Significant

NS

NA

IA administration

 Wong et al. (1)

2010

1.5 g/100 mL after cement

33

35

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Wong et al. (2)

2010

3 g/100 mL after cement

31

35

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Ishida et al.

2011

2 g/20 mL at closure

50

50

NA

NA

NS

NS

 Sa-Ngasoongsong et al.

2011

0.25 g/25 mL at closure

24

24

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Onodera et al.

2012

1 g/50 mL after closure

50

50

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Roy et al.

2012

0.5 g/5 mL

25

25

NA

Significant

NS

NS

 Alshryda et al.

2013

1 g/50 mL at closure

79

78

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Georgiadis et al.

2013

2 g/75 mL

50

51

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Sa-Ngasoongsong et al. (1)

2013

0.25 g/25 mL after closure

45

45

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Sa-Ngasoongsong et al. (2)

2013

0.5 g/25 mL after closure

45

45

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Martin et al.

2014

2 g/100 mL prior to closure

25

25

NA

Significant

NS

NA

 Lin et al.

2015

1 g/20 mL prior to closure

40

40

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Wang et al.

2015

0.5 g/10 mL prior to closure

30

30

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Yang et al.

2015

0.5 g/20 mL prior to closure

40

40

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Maniar et al.

2012

3.0 g/100 mL before deflation for 5 mins

40

40

Significant

NA

NS

NS

 Seo et al.

2013

1.5 g/100 mL

50

50

Significant

NS

NS

Significant

 Sarzaeem et al. (1)

2014

3.0 g TXA/100 mL before suturing

50

50

NA

NS

NS

NS

 Sarzaeem et al. (2)

2014

1.5 g TXA/100 mL after closure

50

50

NA

Significant

NS

NS

 Aguilera et al.

2015

1.0 g/10 mL after cement

50

50

Significant

NS

NS

NS

 Cavusoglu et al.

2015

2.0 g/100 mL before closure

20

20

NA

NA

NS

NA

 Digas et al.

2015

2.0 g TXA after closure

30

30

Significant

NS

NS

NS

 Oztas et al.

2015

2.0 g TXA

30

30

Significant

NA

NS

Significant

 Drosos et al.

2016

1.0 g/30 mL

30

30

Significant

NS

NS

Significant

 Keyhani et al.

2016

1.5 g/50 mL before closure; 1.5 g/50 mL after closure

40

40

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Tzatzairis et al.

2016

1.0 g/100 mL after closure

40

40

Significant

Significant

NS

Significant

 Prakash et al. (1)

2017

3 g/50 ml prior to closure

50

50

NA

NA

NS

NS

 Prakash et al. (2)

2017

3 g/50 ml after closure

50

50

NA

NA

NS

NS

 Song et al.

2017

3 g/50 ml after closure

50

50

Significant

Significant

NS

NS

 Stowers et al.

2017

1.5 g TXA

59

21

Significant

NA

NS

NS

 Ugurlu et al.

2017

1.5 g/50 mL before closure; 1.5 g/50 mL after closure

42

41

NA

Significant

NS

NS

 Yuan et al.

2017

3 g/60 ml after closure

140

140

NA

Significant

NS

Significant

  1. NA not available, NS not significant