Skip to main content

Table 5 Results of subgroup analysis affecting physical function heterogeneity

From: Effects of mind–body exercise on knee osteoarthritis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Groups

No. of studies

No. of Participants

SMD[95%CI]

Heterogeneity

P

P

I2

Exercise type

 Taichi

10

643

-0.82 [-1.16, -0.48]

0.000

73%

0.000

 Yoga

4

323

-0.66 [-0.95, -0.37]

0.29

20%

0.000

 Baduanjin

4

180

-0.97 [-1.28, -0.66]

0.97

0%

0.000

Duration time

 < 12 weeks

5

174

-0.72 [-1.04, -0.41]

0.66

0%

0.000

 12 weeks

9

718

-0.71 [-0.95, -0.47]

0.04

50%

0.000

 > 12 weeks

4

254

-1.14 [-1.62, -0.66]

0.03

68%

0.000

Frequency

 2 sessions per week

4

306

-0.49 [-0.89, -0.08]

0.12

48%

0.02

 3 sessions per week

8

562

-0.83 [-1.07, -0.59]

0.12

39%

0.000

 4–5 sessions per week

6

278

-1.03 [-1.38, -0.67]

0.09

48%

0.000

Gender

 Females

5

215

-1.03 [-1.31, -0.74]

0.64

0%

0.000

 Females/males

13

931

-0.78 [-1.02, -0.54]

0.001

64%

0.000

Region

 Asia

9

475

-0.99 [-1.25, -0.73]

0.08

43%

0.000

 Non-Asia

9

671

-0.62 [-0.85, -0.40]

0.12

37%

0.000