Arthroscopic guided biopsy and radiofrequency thermoablation of a benign neoplasm of the tibial spines area: a treatment option
© Zoccali et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Received: 15 April 2011
Accepted: 4 April 2012
Published: 4 April 2012
Lesions located in the area of the tibial spines are rare. In most cases, treatment follows histological diagnosis, but when imaging and clinical data are considered to be "very" characteristic for benign lesions, such as chondroblastoma or osteoid osteoma, treatment may be performed without biopsy. Traditional curettage requires opening the joint, which presents a high risk of contamination of the joint itself and surrounding structures, such as the popliteal area, with possible contamination of the neurovascular bundle when performing curettage with the posterior approach. In this case, the re-excision of a local recurrence would be extremely difficult.
We describe a technique using arthroscopic guidance for radiofrequency thermoablation of a benign lesion in the tibial spines area. We report on an illustrative case. The patient so treated, reported immediate relief from the pain, and after two weeks, was free of pain. The biopsy performed before the treatment confirmed the radiological diagnosis of chondroblastoma. At one year of follow-up, the patient is without pain, with a 0-130°range of motion, has no activity limitations and is apparently free of disease.
This technique allows a radiofrequency thermoablation of a lesion in the tibial spines area and in the posterior tibial surface to be performed without opening the joint, monitoring the tibial plateau surface, probably decreasing the risk of cartilage damage. Unfortunately, in the case presented, the high pressure from the arthroscopy's pump broke the tibial plateau surface creating a communication to the tibial tunnel used for thermoablation.
KeywordsRadiofrequency thermoablation Tibial spines Osteoid osteoma Chondroblastoma Arthroscopic guided biopsy I declare that we have no commercial interest in the subject under study and that we have not received any financial or material support
Tumors located in the tibial spines area are unusual. Biopsy is difficult because of the high risk of contamination of the joint, therefore, it should be done under guidance of a CT-scan. In some cases where radiologic imaging is characteristic for benign lesions, such as chondroblastoma or osteoid osteoma, treatment may be performed at the same time as biopsy, ideally with an expert pathologist available for intraoperative histology.
This paper reports an unusual case of chondroblastoma located in the tibial spines and describes an arthroscopic technique used to guide an extra-articular biopsy, followed immediately by Radiofrequency Thermoablation (RT) of the tumor.
Results and discussion
Case report and technique description
A 28 year-old male was referred to our department complaining of pain in his right knee for the last four years. During that time, he had undergone three arthroscopies for suspected meniscopathy without any results.
The exploratory arthroscopy confirmed the absence of intra-articular disease, therefore a biopsy was carried out and an arthroscopic-guided RT was performed. A frozen section was not obtained because the imaging and clinical aspect were considered clear.
The patient gave his permission for publication of his images and his case
Access was provided via the routine parapatellar inferior anterolateral and anteromedial portals, avoiding the fat pad. Exploratory arthroscopy identified the tibial spines.
Following extraction of the biopsy specimen, the same access was used for the RF thermoablation of the tumor. The system used was a monopolar "angiodynamics RITA Model 1500X®" with a "StarBurst®"multi-tined expandable probe with seven tips.
The radiofrequency probe was placed at the lesion; placement and expansion were again confirmed radiographically by the C-arm, and the RT was done, reaching a temperature of 100°C for ten minutes.
The arthroscopy permitted the monitoring of the articular surface during the entire procedure and no changes were visible. Unfortunately, in this case, the high pressure from the arthroscopy's water pump broke the tibial plateau surface after the RT, creating a communication between the joint and the access tunnel used for the treatment (Figure 2).
Fortunately, this did not influence the results, and after one year of follow-up no sign of any recurrence is present at MRI and CT-scans (Figure 3). It is also possible to note the wide effect of the treatment; RT was not limited to the lesion area but also took in the surrounding tissue, thus in the postoperative imaging the treated area looks bigger than the original disease area. This explains the possible advantage of a direct view of the cartilage, allowing the procedure to be stopped in case of any visible change in the aspect of the cartilage, and to pull the probe slightly backward and successively start the radiofrequency thermoablation again.
The preferred approach to biopsy of lesions in the tibial spines area is by CT-guidance, using an access point, which avoids joint space to decrease the risk of neoplastic contamination. Nevertheless, in selected cases, radiologic findings are so strongly characteristic of benign lesions that biopsy and ablative therapy may be planned as a single, two-step operative procedure. Here we have presented a case in which the imaging and clinical data (very slow growth) was highly suggestive of chondroblastoma, a benign tumor typical of the epiphysis. In this case, treatment was carried out at the same time as the biopsy.
Benign chondroblastomais often localized in epiphyseal areas. It is usually found in patients between 10 and 20 years of age, and less frequently in patients between 21 and 30 years of age. The imaging is typical of an osteolytic rounded lesion, with smooth, well-defined borders and sometimes calcifications. On CT and MRI scans, the lesion appears to be parenchymatous, occasionally with cystic cavities and fluid levels .
The gold standard in the treatment of chondroblastoma is curettage, with or without the use of local adjuvants.
When the lesion is located under the anterior part of the tibial articular surface the surgical approach is anterior; when the lesion is located under the tibial spines area or posterior, the approach should be posterior because of the presence of cruciate ligaments, identifying the popliteal neurovascular bundles.
Today, RT has become a minimally invasive alternative to surgery , eliminating the need for capsule opening and the accompanying increased risk of joint and popliteal area contamination and recurrence, which has historically been very difficult to treat. The approach proposed here allows treatment of the lesion without opening the joint so that any possible recurrence in the tibia would be less difficult to treat, either by curettage or by repeat radiofrequency thermoablation.
A CT-guided RT is probably easier than the arthroscope-guided procedure described herein, because it allows for more accurate verification of the correct placement of the RT probe. However, CT-guidance does not allow for the cartilage surface to be directly monitored during the RT, otherwise possible with the arthroscopic procedure described here, probably decreasing the risk of damage to these tissues during the ablation therapy. Unfortunately, no studies about the changes induced by RT are available in literature, nevertheless, in our case, no changes were noted during the procedure. If any variation in the aspect and color of the cartilage were noted, radiofrequency thermoablation could be stopped and restarted after pulling the probe backward and positioning it farther from the cartilage or after decreasing the working temperature.
Unfortunately, in the case presented here, the high pressure from the arthroscopy's water pump broke the tibial joint surface and created a communication between the joint and the disease area. This happened because the water pressure was not decreased during and after the procedure, rather than as a direct consequence of the treatment. The rupture occurred after RT when theoretically the tumoral cells had died, therefore local relapse risk is, definitely, less than that of traditional curettage: the high temperature achieved by RT created a significant necrosis, so the patient remains disease-free at one year of follow-up.
Attention must be paid to minimize the intra-articular water pressure during and after the procedure of arthroscope-guided radiofrequency thermoablation.
The arthroscopic procedure can be performed in any hospital where arthroscopic and RF instruments are available. However, the CT-guided procedure requires, in addition to RF instrumentation, an anesthesia-supported CT suite, which is not widely available. Indeed both procedures require general or epidural anesthesia.
The main advantage of our technique is to allow the treatment of benign lesions in the tibial spines area and in the posterior part of the tibial articular surface where a posterior approach is needed without opening the joint for curettage. Moreover, this technique should permit the cartilage to be directly monitored during the procedure, and because of its safety and relative ease, it can be performed by surgeons at varying levels of expertise in arthroscopic procedures. Nevertheless, more studies need to be conducted to describe the possible cartilage damage.
The upper size limit of the lesions potentially treated by RF depends on the opening of the probe tips technically possible up to 5 cm; nevertheless this size cannot be obtain within the bone and the radiofrequency application would not be uniform, therefore, in our opinion, lesions bigger than 3 cm in diameter should not be treated.
A fundamental requirement of this treatment is that it must only be done after histologic confirmation of a benign lesion, or when radiologic imaging is strongly characteristic of a benign lesion.
The patient has given his consent for the publication of his case and his images.
- Springfield DS, Capanna R, Gherlinzoni F, Picci P, Campanacci M, Chondroblastoma: A review of seventy cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1985, 67 (5): 748-755.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rybak LD, Rosenthal DI, Wittig JC: Chondroblastoma: radiofrequency ablation--alternative to surgical resection in selected cases. Radiology. 2009, 251 (2): 599-604. 10.1148/radiol.2512080500. Epub 2009 Mar 20View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2474/13/52/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.