Skip to main content

Table 2 Observer agreement for relative and absolute CEA-BML and STIR-BML measurements, and relative Nvoxel, irrespective of baseline/follow-up

From: Assessment of subchondral bone marrow lesions in knee osteoarthritis by MRI: a comparison of fluid sensitive and contrast enhanced sequences

Method

Area

Image sequence

Observer agreement

CEA-BML, STIR-BML and Nvoxel, relative

CEA-BML, STIR-BML and Nvoxel, absolute

Biasa,%

95% CI

Biasa, mm3/mm2b

95% CI

MS

Femur

T1 CE FS

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

−0.86

−0.98

−2.68

−2.37

0.95

0.42

−79

−94

−281

−199

122

11

Tibia

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

−0.67

−0.89

−4.2

−2.64

2.8

0.86

18

−58

−321

−147

358

31

Femur

STIR

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

−0.36

1.15

−1.45

−0.46

0.73

2.76

7

142

−129

−41

144

325

Tibia

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

−0.26

1.18

−0.82

−0.06

1.35

2.41

−83

129

−209

6

44

251

CAS

Femur

T1 CE FS

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

0.23

−0.37

−1.22

−1.03

1.68

0.29

108

−71

−59

−185

276

43

Tibia

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

0.29

0.18

−1.57

−0.30

2.15

0.67

14

3

−94

−36

122

42

Femur

STIR

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

0.01

−0.10

−0.41

−0.42

0.43

0.21

15

67

−60

13

89

121

Tibia

Inter-observer

Intra-observer

−0.10

0.22

−0.70

−0.04

0.51

0.49

−74

61

−140

28

9

94

Dynamika

Femur

Tibia

DCE-MRI

Intra-observer

Intra-observer

−2.75

−2.5

−4.56

−5.37

−0.94

0.37

−27

−7

−50

−29

−5

15

  1. aBland-Altman analysis
  2. bCEA-BML and STIR-BML in mm3, Nvoxel in mm2