Skip to main content

Table 2 Proportion (%) of people with radiographic knee OA in populations with knee pain according to the definition of knee pain.

From: The discordance between clinical and radiographic knee osteoarthritis: A systematic search and summary of the literature

Study

% Radiographic OA in those

with Knee pain

Definition of knee pain positive subjects

Hannan [25]

15

Pain, swelling, morning stiffness in or around the knee on most days for one month

  

Positive response to both parts required:

Lanyon [8]

30

(A) Have you ever had pain in or around the knee on most days for one month?

McAlindon [15]

53

 

McAlindon [17]

76

 

Lethbridge [10]

53

(B) If so, have you experienced pain in the last year?

Felson [20] (Part A only)

16

 

Cicuttinni [11]

37

Ever having an episode of knee pain

Cicuttinni [26]

30

Ever having an episode of knee pain lasting more than 15 days

Peterson [19]

15

Pain in your knees practically daily for the last 3 months

Lachance [13]

15 (CA)

40 (AA)

Any joint pain in their knees during the last during the last month

Hart [18]

19

Pain, stiffness and swelling lasting more than a month

Odding [14]

39

Knee pain during the past month

Jordan [35]

N/A

Knee pain on most days

Davis [27]

N/A

Knee pain on most days lasting for one month in the past year

Williams [21]

N/A

 

Brandt [24]

N/A

 

Ang [23]

N/A

 
  1. CA – Caucasian, AA – African American, N/A – not applicable.