Skip to main content

Table 2 Outcome measures

From: Effects of home-based resistance training and neuromuscular electrical stimulation in knee osteoarthritis: a randomized controlled trial

 

NMES (n = 10)

RT (n = 10)

Control (n = 6)

 

Week 1

Week 8

Week 14

Week 1

Week 8

Week 14

Week 1

Week 8

Week 14

Walk Test (s)

15.43±3.61

13.85±3.79*

13.08±4.08*

16.81±3.39

14.07±3.40*

14.50±3.71*

16.64±3.64

16.30±3.58

11.55±4.10

Chair Rise Test (s)

7.37±2.05

6.35±1.46*

5.79±1.20*

8.33±1.45

5.97±0.58*

6.18±1.05*

8.16±2.23

8.01±2.17

5.20±1.11

Stair Climb Test (s)

14.31±5.11

11.87±4.21*

12.48±6.44*

15.12±5.32

11.78±4.54*

11.84±5.03*

13.27±5.36

13.06±5.84

9.63±2.99

WOMAC Physical Function

41.04±11.60

33.88±12.66

31.50±12.63*

31.68±12.92

33.91±12.91

31.50±14.40

31.67±17.95

26.11±15.33

21.67±18.90

WOMAC Pain

11.50±3.50

8.88±3.29*

8.50±2.72

11.05±3.02

10.78±4.31

9.60±4.14

9.00±3.65

8.33±4.36

8.33±4.08

WOMAC Stiffness

5.17±2.17

3.92±2.15

4.10±2.18

5.23±0.68

4.73±1.74

4.45±2.24

5.22±1.72

4.11±1.83

4.00±2.37

SF-36 Physical Health

39.25±16.95

50.50±16.60*

47.60±10.73

39.73±16.51

50.00±23.12

53.20±25.09

51.78±24.34

56.00±24.74

67.83±21.71

SF-36 Mental Health

60.67±26.45

70.67±21.84

65.40±12.98

56.36±21.91

66.64±20.36

65.30±24.91

62.00±25.41

65.00±27.77

70.50±22.40

Isometric Peak Torque (Nm)

88.16±31.21

92.59±36.66

86.65±31.21

82.55±22.39

87.16±17.84

86.87±21.44

92.99±47.89

100.30±32.80

97.35±44.76

Isokinetic Peak Torque (Nm)

67.33±19.42

71.37±23.89

66.36±20.18

64.52±21.74

71.79±17.27

70.91±21.83

75.10±28.45

75.91±28.83

77.80±47.45

Quadriceps CSA (mm2)

4061±721

4279±784*

 

4335±610

4521±651*

    
  1. Values are mean ± standard deviation.
  2. * P significant vs. week 1 (P < 0.0056).
  3. NMES, Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation Group; RT, Resistance Training Group; WOMAC, Western Ontario McMaster Osteoarthritis index.
  4. SF-36, Short Form 36; CSA: Cross-sectional area.