Skip to main content

Table 1 Principal demographic and clinical features of patients studied

From: Comparative effectiveness of three treatment options for slade and dodds grade III-IV scaphoid nonunion: a retrospective study

Nonunion Grade

Grade III

Grade IV

Item

Group A

Group B

Group C

P-value

Group A

Group B

Group C

P-value

Age

23 (19 to 50)

26 (18 to 38)

28 (20 to 46)

0.71

23 (19 to 30)

28 (22 to 38)

24 (18 to 31)

0.06

Sex M/F

10/1

7/0

7/0

0.52

10/0

6/1

9/2

0.38

Injured side L/R

7/4

3/4

3/4

0.59

6/4

3/4

5/6

0.73

Dominance Y/N

9/2

4/3

4/3

0.42

6/4

5/2

6/5

0.77

Time from initial injury to surgery (Mo)

8 (6 to 24)

7 (6 to 16)

8 (6 to 10)

0.48

10 (6 to 15)

9 (6 to 15)

11 (6 to 24)

0.67

Current smoker Y/N

3/8

2/5

2/5

0.99

3/7

2/5

4/7

0.93

Diabetes Y/N

2/9

1/6

2/5

0.78

2/8

1/6

1/10

0.78

  1. Group A, open surgery debridement, bone grafting, and internal fixation; Group B, percutaneous Screw Fixation; Group C,percutaneous screw fixation and PRP injection. M male, F female, L left, R right, Y yes, N no, Mo month