Table 6 Surgical outcome characteristics of the non-snapping group
From: The effect of iliotibial band surgery at the hip: a systematic review
Year, author | Syndrome, snapping | Surgical intervention (Study description) | Additional bursectomy | Surgical approach | Patients included, hips | PROM, preoperative, mean (range) | PROM, postoperative mean (range) | Pain score, preoperative | Pain score, postoperative | Relief of pain; complete, partial, none | Snapping eliminated | Complications (yes, no) | Repeated surgery (n) | Reuse of conservative treatment (n) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1979, Brooker et al [8] | GTB, n/a | ITB-release (T-shape) | n/a | Open | 5, 5 | HHS = 46 (n/a) | HHS = 88 (n/a) | n/a | n/a | 4,1,0 | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
1997, Slawski et al [57] | GTB, no | ITB-release (vertical) | Yes | Open | 5, 7 | HHS = 51.7 (45–56) | HHS = 95 (84–100) | n/a | n/a | 1,2,1 | IRLVT | 0, 4 | 0 | 1 |
2007, Craig et al [10] | GTPS (GTB), n/a | Z-plasty | Yes | Open | 15, 17 | HHS = 46 (n/a) | HHS = 82 (n/a) | Pain-score = 11,7 A | Pain score = 31.2 A | 8,8,1B | n/a | 2, 13 | 1 | n/a |
2009, Pretell et al [43] | GTB, no | Distal Z-plasty | n/a | Open | 11, 13 | HHS = 61 (48–77) | HHS = 91 (76–95) | VAS = 8.3 (6–9.9) | VAS = 1.3 (0–7) | 12,0,1B | IRLVT | 2, 9 | 1 | n/a |
2014, Domínguez et al [12] | GTPS, yes | Diamond-shaped release | Yes | Endoscopic | 23, 23 | mHHS = 40.2 (n/a) WOMAC 63.3 | mHHS = 86.3 (n/a) WOMAC 5.2 | VAS = 8.1 (n/a) | VAS = 0.5 (n/a) | 23,0,0 | 22/23 | 1, 22 | 0 | n/a |
2016, Drummond et al[13] | GTPS, n/a | ITB-release (vertical) | Yes | Endoscopic | 49, 57 | iHOT-33 = 23.8 (n/a) | iHOT-33 = 70.2 (n/a) | VAS = 7.8 (n/a) | VAS = 2.8 (n/a) | 14,36,7B | n/a | 0, 49 | 0 | 14B |
2019, Thomassen et al [59] | GTPS, no | ITB-release (star-shaped) | Yes | Endoscopic | 11c, 11 | HHS = n/a | HHS = 73.8 (41–86) | NRS = 8 (7–9) | NRS = 4 (2–6) | 0,11,0 | IRLVT | 1, 10 | 1 | 10 |
2020, Blakey et al [3] | GTPS (GT), n/a | Diamond-shaped release | Yes | Endoscopic | 33, 33 | mHHS = 58.2 (SD = 11.5) | mHHS = 78.8 (SD = 18.6) | VAS = n/a | VAS = 33.3-improvement | 23,0,10 | n/a | 2, 31 | 2 | n/a |
2021, Dzidzishvili et al [14] | GTPS (GTB), n/a | ITB-Release (cross- shaped) | Yes | Endoscopic | 58, 60 | HOS = 24.1 (n/a) | HOS = 70.6 (n/a) | VAS = 9.6 (n/a) | VAS = 2.1 (n/a) | 50,0,8 | n/a | 6, 52 | 2 | 6 |