Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies

From: Risk factors and modes of failure in the modern dual mobility implant. A systematic review and meta-analysis

Author, Year Study design No. of THA procedure Indications Mean age (yrs) Follow up duration (m) Implant type A B C D E F G H
2020 Tabori-jensen Prospective series 59 Primary 75 24 1 V V V V V V V  
2020 Schmidt Retrospective series 184 Revision 69 24 2, 3 V V V V V V   
2020 Rashed Prospective series 31 Primary 66.4 12 4    V V    V  
2020 Nessler Retrospective series 93 Primary 65.5 32.4 5 V V V V V    
2020 Laende Retrospective series 27 Primary 63 36 6 V V V V V V   
2020 Klemt Retrospective series 42 Revision 55 48 1, 5, 6, 10, 13 V V V V V V   
2020 Hoggett Retrospective series 28 Recurrent dislocation 80 55 3, 7 V V V V V V   
2020 Favreau Retrospective series 40 Revision 77 54 3 V V V V V V V V
2020 Dubin Retrospective series 664 Primary 61.7 25 5, 6 V V V V V V V  
2020 Dubin (Arthroplasty Today) Retrospective series 142 Primary 67 68.4 6 V V V V V V   
2020 de l’Escalopier Retrospective series 84 Revision 71 65.3 8, 9 V V V V V V   V
2020 Colacchio Retrospective series 29 Revision 61.4 47 6, 10 V V V V V V   
2020 Civinini Retrospective series 37 Revision 63.7 61.2 5        V  
2020 Ait Mokhtar Retrospective series 148 Primary 78 38 2 V V V V V V   
2020 Abdel Retrospective series 126 Revision 66 43.2 5 V V V V V V   
2019 Ukaj Prospective series 47 Primary 78.1 36 2 V V V V V V V  
2019 Tabori-jensen, Arch Retrospective series 997 Primary 80.5 64.8 1, 11 V V V V V V   
2019 Schmidt-braekling Retrospective series 77 Revision 68.5 63.6 1, 4 V V V V V V V  
2019 Nonne Retrospective series 60 Primary 87.6 28.3 12 V V V V V V V  
2019 Neil Wheelton Retrospective series 54 Revision 78 22.8 NR V V V V V V   
2019 Nam Prospective series 43 Primary 52.6 24 5        V  
2019 Markel Prospective series 21 Primary 61.7 24 5        V  
2019 Li Retrospective series 94 Revision 63.6 37.8 5    V V   V   
2019 Kreipke Retrospective series 2277 Primary 75.5 35.9 1, 11, 13 V V V V V V   
2019 Jones Retrospective series 151 Primary 82 43.2 6 V V V V V V   
2019 Jobory Retrospective series 4520 Primary 77 25.2 1, 11, 13 V V    V V   
2019 Iorio Retrospective series 30 Primary 82 12 2 V V V V V V   
2019 Huang Retrospective series 315 Revision 65.8 39.6 5 V V V V V V V  
2019 Huang Retrospective series 107 Recurrent dislocation 65.8 39.6 5    V V     
2019 Gaillard Retrospective series 138 Primary 68 152.4 11 V V V V V V V V
2019 Fessy Retrospective series 541 Primary 73.6 103.2 3 V V V V V V V  
2019 Fahad Retrospective series 27 Primary 69.3 19 NR    V V V   V  
2019 Dubin Retrospective series 287 Primary 67.8 34.3 6 V V V V V V V  
2019 Dubin Retrospective series 287 Primary 67.9 34.3 5 V V V V V V V  
2019 Dikmen Prospective series 34 Revision 66.1 42.24 13 V V V V V V V  
2019 Cypres Retrospective series 244 Primary 63.8 142.8 13 V V V V V V   V
2019 Chalmers Retrospective series 24 Revision 63 48 5        V  
2019 Canton Retrospective series 31 Primary 76.7 67.2 1 V V V V    V  
2019 Boulat Retrospective series 33 Primary 74 44 3 V V V V V V V V
2019 Bloemheuvel Retrospective series 3038 Primary 70 36 1, 2, 11, 13, 14 V V V V V V   
2019 Bloemheuvel Retrospective series 4637 Revision 74 72 1, 2, 11, 13, 14 V V    V V   
2019 Assi(J Arthroplasty) Retrospective series 125 Primary 78.1 61.2 1, 2 V V V V    V  
2019 Assi(Int Orthop) Retrospective series 16 Revision 69.2 72.9 NR V V V V V V V  
2019 Assi(Hip Int.) Retrospective series 229 Primary 62 70 1, 2 V V V V V V V  
2019 Addona Retrospective series 107 Primary NR NR 5; 15    V V   V   
2019 Addona Retrospective series 47 Revision NR NR 5; 15    V V   V   
2018 Tabori-Jensen Retrospective series 124 Primary 74.7 33.6 11 V V V V V V V  
2018 Stucinskas Retrospective series 247 Revision 72 24 1; 2 V V V V V V   
2018 Spaans Retrospective series 102 Recurrent dislocation 73.1 27.6 1 V V V V V V   
2018 Rashed Prospective series 32 Primary 66.4 12 4 V V V V V V V  
2018 Perrin Prospective series 24 Revision 79.5 6 NR V V V V V V   
2018 Ozden Retrospective series 20 Revision 64.5 38.1 13 V V V V V V V  
2018 Marie-hardy Retrospective series 16 Primary 69.6 29 3 V V V V V V   V
2018 Lange Retrospective series 40 Recurrent dislocation 64 36 5; 6 V V V V V V   
2018 Kim Retrospective series 84 Primary 73.1 21.7 5    V V    V  
2018 Kavcic Retrospective series 173 Primary 76.8 92.4 1 V V V V V V V  
2018 Kasparek Retrospective series 11 Revision 64 31 5; 6 V V V V V V V  
2018 Hwang Prospective series 167 Primary 72 22 10 V V V V V V V  
2018 Harwin Retrospective series 85 Revision 67 48 5 V V V V V V V  
2018 Hartzler Retrospective series 126 Revision 66 40 5    V V   V   
2018 Diamond Retrospective series 60 Revision 65.5 38.6 5 V V V V V V   
2018 Chalmers Retrospective series 14 Recurrent dislocation 65 37 5 V V V V V V V  
2018 Boukebous Retrospective series 98 Primary 77.8 25.9 16, 17    V V     
2018 Assi Retrospective series 30 Primary 54.9 51 1; 2; 19 V V V V V V V  
2017 Viste Retrospective series 334 Revision NR 84 3 V V V V V V   
2017 Tarasevicius Retrospective series 620 Revision 63.2 30 1; 2 V V V V V V   
2017 Sutter Retrospective series 64 Revision 59 38 5 V V V V V V   
2017 Rowan Retrospective series 136 Primary 48.5 38.4 5; 6 V V V V V V V  
2017 Puch Prospective series 103 Primary 49.9 132 20 V V V V V V V V
2017 Puch Prospective series 217 Primary 72.3 149 20 V V V V V V V V
2017 Ochi Retrospective series 33 Primary 80 15.8 5 V V V V V V   
2017 Nam Prospective series 26 Primary 52.8 12 5        V  
2017 Martz Retrospective series 25 Primary 44 129.8 3 V V V V V V V V
2017 Lebeau Retrospective series 62 Revision 75.5 77 2 (1st-gen) V V V V V V V V
2017 Hernigou Retrospective series 35 Revision 73 84 2, 21 V V V V V V   V
2017 Henawy Prospective series 24 Primary 68 12 3 V V V V V V V V
2017 Hamadouche Retrospective series 51 Revision 71.4 60 8 V V V V V V   V
2017 Graversen Retrospective series 20 Primary 83 12 1 V V V V V V   
2017 Gonzalez Prospective series 150 Revision 73 6 13; 22 V V V V V V   
2017 Ferreira Retrospective series 553 Primary 71.2 36 2 V V V V V V   
2017 Ferreira Retrospective series 83 Primary 81.7 36 2 V V V V V V   
2017 Epinette Retrospective series 321 Primary 48.1 32.4 5, 6 V V V V V V V  
2017 Chalmers Retrospective series 16 Revision 75 36 5 V V V V V V V  
2017 Batailler Retrospective series 302 Primary 73 14 2, 23 V V V V V V V V
2016 Nich Retrospective series 45 Primary 86.7 23.8 6; 24 V V V V V V   V
2016 Morin Retrospective series 40 Primary 19.2 60 NR V V V V V V   
2016 Jauregui Retrospective series 60 Revision 57 30 5 V V V V V V V  
2016 Homma Retrospective series 60 Primary 75.6 6 5; 6 V V V V V V   
2016 Haughom Retrospective series 24 Primary 50.2 3 NR    V V     
2016 Griffin Prospective series 10 Primary >60 12 3 V V V V V V   
2016 Chughtai Retrospective series 410 Primary 64 36 5 V V V V V V V  
2016 Carulli Retrospective series 31 Recurrent dislocation 75.4 45.6 1 V V V V V V V  
2015 Wegrzyn Retrospective series 994 Revision 70 87.6 11 V V V V     
2015 Vigdorchik Retrospective series 485 Primary 66 24 6 V V V V V V V  
2015 Vermersch Prospective series 86 Primary 72 27 3 V V V V V V V V
2015 van Heumen Retrospective series 50 Recurrent dislocation 67 29 1 V V V V V V   
2015 Snir Retrospective series 18 Revision 50.6 26.5 5; 6; 10 V V V V V V V  
2015 Simian Retrospective series 74 Revision 67.9 87.6 17; 18; 25 V V V V V V V V
2015 Mohammed Retrospective series 20 Primary 70.8 22 NR V V V V V V   
2015 Mohammed Retrospective series 24 Revision 76.4 22 NR V V V V V V   
2015 Epinette Prospective series 143 Primary 70.6 50 6 V V V V V V V V
2015 Bel Retrospective series 18 Primary 84 36 3 V V V V V V   
2014 Wegrzyn Prospective series 61 Revision 67 86 11 V V V V V V V  
2014 Prudhon Prospective series 79 Revision 62.5 24 7 V V V V V V   
2014 Jakobsen Retrospective series 56 Recurrent dislocation 72 44 11 V V V V V V V  
2014 Epinette Prospective series 437 Primary 74.2 24 6 V V V V V V V V
2014 Caton Retrospective series 105 Primary 78 120 2 V V V V V V   
2014 Bensen Retrospective series 175 Primary 75.2 21.7 11 V V V V V V   
2013 Tarasevicius Retrospective series 41 Primary 75 12 1 V V V V V V   
2013 Saragaglia Retrospective series 29 Recurrent dislocation 75.6 46 1; 3; 20; 24 V V V V V V   V
2013 Sanders Retrospective series 10 Primary 54 39 1 V V V V V V   
2013 Prudhon Retrospective series 105 Primary 78 91 2 V V V V V V   V
2012 Vasukutty Retrospective series 143 Revision 77 42 NR V V V V V V   
2012 Pattyn Retrospective series 36 Revision 70 16 26 V V V V V V   
2012 Hamadouche Retrospective series 119 Primary 67 72 9 V V V V     V
2012 Hailer Retrospective series 228 Recurrent dislocation 75 24 1 V V V V V V   
2012 Civinini Prospective series 33 Revision 69 36 1 V V V V V V V  
2012 Adam Prospective series 214 Primary 83 9 NR V V V V V V   
2011 Schneider Retrospective series 96 Revision 69.9 41 3 V V V V V V   V
2011 Bouchet Retrospective series 105 Primary 76.6 28 1; 3; 20; 24    V V   V   
2010 Tarasevicius Retrospective series 42 Primary 75 12 1    V V   V   
2010 Hamadouche Retrospective series 47 Recurrent dislocation 71.3 51.4 8 V V V V V V   V
2009 Guyen Retrospective series 54 Recurrent dislocation 66.5 48 11 V V V V V V V  
2008 Langlais Retrospective series 88 Revision 72 36 8 V V V V V V   V
2008 Bauchu Retrospective series 121 Primary 69 74.4 13 V V V V V V   V
  1. A: aseptic loosening; B; septic loosening or PJI; C: extra-dislocation; D: Intra-dislocation; E: Periprosthetic fracture; F: implant failure; G; HHS; H: Merle D’Aubigne scores
  2. 1: Avantage (Zimmer Biomet, Warsaw, Indiana, USA); 2: Quattro (Groupe Lépine, Genay, France ); 3. Novae cup or Novae Sunfit cup (Serf, Décines, France); 4. EcoFit 2M cup (Ecofit, implantcast, Buxtehude, Germany); 5. Stryker MDM (Stryker, Mahwah, New Jersey, USA); 6. Stryker ADM (Stryker, Mahwah, New Jersey, USA); 7. ADES (Zimmer Biomet, Warsaw, Indiana, USA); 8. Medial cup (Aston Medical, Saint-Étienne, France); 9. Tregor cup (Aston Medical, Saint-Étienne, France); 10. Biomet Active Articulation E1 (Biomet Orthopedics, Warsaw, Indiana, USA); 11. Saturne (Amplitude, Valence, France); 12. Dualis acetabular cup (Gruppo Bioimpianti, Peschiera Borromeo, Milano, Italy); 13. Polarcup (Smith & Nephew AG, Aarau, Switzerland); 14. SeleXys DS cup (Mathys European Orthopaedics, Bettlach, Switzerland); 15. G7 DM (Zimmer Biomet, Warsaw, Indiana, USA); 16. Galiléa (SEM, Créteil, France); 17. Evora (SEM, Créteil, France); 18. DMS (SEM, Créteil, France); 19. Hip’n Go dual mobility (FH orthopedics, Mulhouse, France); 20. Gyros cup (Depuy, Warsaw, IN, USA); 21. Ceraver DM device (Ceraver Osteal, Roissy, France); 22. Versafit DM cup (Medacata international, Castel San Pietro, Switzerland); 23. Tornier DM cup (Tornier, Montbonnot-Saint-Martin, France); 24. Stafit (Zimmer, Etupes, France); 25. Mobilite (Tornier, Montbonnot-Saint-Martin, France); 26. Apogee DM socket (Biotechni Inc., Marseille, France)