Skip to main content

Table 3 Literature review of Allografts Prosthesis Composite for the tumoral skeletal defects in proximal femur

From: Long-term results of uncemented allograft prosthesis composite reconstruction for the tumor in proximal femur: a minimum follow-up of sixty-five months

References No Reasons Folllow-up (months) Type of Acetabulum Union time (months) Type of fixation OR (%) Complications LS (%) Assessment
Tu RHA THA Bi CA UCA PCA AP AL SF IN TP/D Non Ins HHS MSTS (%)
Gitelis [12] 11 11 / / / / / 7 / 4 4 / / / / / / / / / /
Zehr [13] 18 18 / 63,2 (9–122) 11 7 13.5 (12–15) 14 2 2 2 / / / 3 / 1 / 94 / 77.7 (67–83)
McGoveran [11] 16 16 / 47 (24–93) / / / 5 / 11 2 43.8 / 3 3 / 2 / 100 / 58.3
Donati [30] 27 27 / 58 (11–126) 3 24 7 (3–12) 4 / 23 / 18.2 / 1 1 5 1 / 100 / 92 (75–100)
Langlais [15] 21 21 / 72 / / / 21 / / / 38 4 / / 10 4 / 100 / 76.9 (43–97)
Farid [31] 20 20 / 77.5 (24–335) / / / 18 / 2 / 40 / / 1 8 2 2 100 / 82
Lee [16] 15 1 14 50.4 (24–117.6) 15 / 11.6 (4–16) 3 / 12 / 26.7 2 / 1 / 2 1 / 83.2 (67–96) /
Biau [17] 32 32 / 68 (2–232) 22 10 / 32 / / / 28.1 1 3 4 1 / / 100 / /
Muscolo [18] 38 26 12 90 (36–204) 38 / / / / 38 38 29 / 7 3 1 / / 96 / 90 (43.3–100)
Malhotra [19] 18 18 / 54 (18–79) 18 / 6.8 (4.5–11) / / 18 / / / / / / / / 100 90.3 (84–96) /
Min [23] 12 12 / 24 (16–35) 7 5 (5–9) / 12 / / / / / / / / / 100 81.6 (66.2–92.7) 87.3 (80–96.7)
Min [20] 28 28 / 50.7 (15–138) 17 11 (9–18) 28 / / / 3.6 / 2 / / 6 / 100 80.6 (66.2–92.7) 88.3 (70–96.7)
Dubor y[1] 46 32 14 176.4 (75.6–391.2) 32 14 / 42 2 2 / / 4 6 3 5 7 4 / / 77 (50–96.7)
Current series 18 18 / 106.7 (65–141) 18 / 7.6 (5–10) / 18 / / 22.2 / 2 / 3 / / 94.4 83 (48–100) 80 (33.3–100)
  1. Abbreviations: No Number, Tu Tumor, RHA Revision of hip arthroplasty, THA Total hip arthroplasty, Bi Bipolar, CA Cemented allograft composite, UCA Uncemented allograft composite, PCA Partial cemented allograft composite, AP Additional plate, OR Overall revision rate, AL Aseptic loosening, SF Structural failure, IN Infection, TP Tumor progressing, D Death, Non Non-union, Ins Instability, LS Limb Salvage, HHS Harries Hip Score, MSTS Musculoskeletal Tumor Society