Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary of cemented PEG and modern MBG

From: Loosening and revision rates after total shoulder arthroplasty: a systematic review of cemented all-polyethylene glenoid and three modern designs of metal-backed glenoid

 

Cemented PEG (n = 3312)

Modern MBG (n = 457)

P–value

Age (years)

Number of cases/articles

3062/24

367/8

NA

Mean

66.4 (21–93)

66.5 (31–88)

Follow–up duration (months)

Number of cases/articles

3312/25

457/10

NA

Mean

73.1 (12–211)

56.1

Gain of FE (°)

Number of cases/articles

1387/14

142/2

NA

Mean

48.6

61.7

Gain of ER (°)

Number of cases/articles

1304/14

161/3

NA

Mean

24.2

39.2

Constant score improvement

Number of cases/articles

1208/9

3/97

NA

Mean

34.8

40.4

ASES score improvement

Number of cases/articles

226/5

135/3

NA

Mean

44.5

56.5

Primary osteoarthritis

Yes (%)

2866 (86.5%)

350 (88.4%)

0.310

No (%)

446 (13.5%)

46 (11.6%)

Diagnosis unknown

1

61

Radiolucent lines

Present (%)

354 (27.2%)

22 (4.9%)

NA

Absent (%)

948 (72.8%)

427 (95.1%)

Not reported

2010

8

Loosening

Present (%)

465 (14.6%)

22 (4.9%)

NA

Absent (%)

2720 (85.4%)

427 (95.1%)

Not reported

127

8

Revision surgery

Present (%)

189 (5.7%)

11 (2.4%)

NA

Absent (%)

3127 (94.3%)

446 (97.6%)

Not reported

0

0

  1. PEG all-polyethylene glenoid, MBG metal-backed glenoid, NA not applicable, FE forward elevation, ER external rotation, ASES American shoulder and elbow surgeons