Skip to main content

Table 3 Distribution and prevalence of co-occurring musculoskeletal pain among individuals with persistent low back pain grouped by study population

From: Distribution and prevalence of musculoskeletal pain co-occurring with persistent low back pain: a systematic review

1st Author Year

Axial pain n/N (%) [non-weighted] ♀ / ♂ (if reported)

Extremity pain n/N (%)[non-weighted] ♀ / ♂ (if reported)

Other co-occurring MSK pain sites/no. of pain sites n/N (%)[non-weighted] ♀ / ♂ (if reported)

No. of options for pain sites and regions in addition to LBP

General population

 Jiménez-Trujillo 2019 [37]

+ neck: 2963/5189 (57.1) ♀ 2089/2963 (70.5)a ♂ 874/2963 (29.5)a

 

+ headached: 1130/5189 (21.8) ♀ 860/1130 (76.1) ♂ 270/1130 (23.9)

 

2 (neck, headache)

 Fujii 2018 [34]

 

+ knee: 639/3100 (20.6)

+ headached: 1004/3100 (32.4)

+ arms, legs or joints: 1336/3100 (43.1)

3 (knee, headache, arms/legs/joints)

 Takahashi 2018 [47]

 

+ knee: 364/1378 (26.4)a, b

  

1 (knee)

 Nordstoga 2017 [43]

  

+  1–2 pain sites: 2331/7523 (31.0)a ♀ 1180/2331 (50.6)a ♂ 1151/2331 (49.4)a

+  3–8 pain sites: 4412/7523 (58.6) ♀ 2978/4412 (67.5)a ♂ 1434/4412 (32.4)a

8 (neck, shoulders/ upper arms, elbows, wrists/ hands, upper back, hips, knees, ankles/ feet)

 Kamada 2014 [38]

 

+ knee: 152/ 605 (25.1)c

 

1 (knee)

 Di lorio 2007 [32]

 

+ hip: 62a/306 (20.3) + knee: 87a/306 (28.4) + foot: 99a/306 (32.4)

 

3 (hip, knee, foot)

 Weiner 2003 [48]

 

+ hip: 80a/208 (38.7) + knee: 99a/208 (47.6)

 

2 (hip, knee)

 Natvig 2001 [42]

  

+  1–3 pain sites: 167/531 (31.5)c ♀100/167 (59.9)c ♂ 67/167 (40.1)c

+  4–9 pain sites (“widespread”): 244/531 (46.0)c ♀ 162/244 (66.4)c ♂ 82/244 (33.6)c

9 (headd, neck, shoulder, elbow, hand/wrist, upper back, hip, knee or ankle/foot)

 Kjellman 2001 [39]

+ neck-shoulder: 32a/100 (32.0)

  

1 (neck/shoulder)

 Hoddevik 1999 [36]

   

+ other MSK pain: 5057/6422 (78.7)a ♀ 3252/5057 (64.3)a ♂ 1805/5057 (35.7)a

1 (other MSK)

Working population

 Andersen 2013 [30]

+ neck-shoulder: ♀ 632/1089 (58.0)

+ knee: ♀ 294/1089 (27.0)

 

2 (neck/shoulder, knee)

 Parot-Schinkel 2013 [45]

  

+  1–3 pain sites: 353/616 (57.3)a ♀ 145/264 (≈ 55)a ♂ 208/352 (≈ 59)a

+  4–8 pain sites: 82/616 (13.3) ♀ 50/264 (≈ 19) ♂ 32/352 (≈ 9)

8 (neck, shoulder/ arm, elbow/forarm, wrist/ hand, upper back, hip/thigh, knee/lower leg, ankle/foot)

Clinical population

 Rundelle 2019 [46]

+ neck: 415/899 (46.2)

+ pelvic or groin: 251/899 (27.9)

+ headached: 260/899 (28.9)

+ arms, legs or joints: 801/899 (89.1) + widespread: 266/899 (29.6)

6 (neck, pelvic/groin, headache, stomach, arms/legs/joints, widespread)

 Herman 2018 [35]

+ neck: 611/1129 (54.1)a

   

1 (neck)

 MacLellan 2017 [40]

  

+  1 pain site: 177/416 (42.6)a

+ ≥2 pain sites: 161/416 (38.7)a

4 (knee, other MSK [not specified which other MSK for those with persistent LBP (i.e. upper- and lower extremity, spinal /headached)]

 Panagopoulos 2014 [44]

  

+ chest-abdomen-groin: 583/2974 (19.6) ♀ 303/1576 (19.2)a ♂ 280/1398 (20.0)a

1 (trunk)

 Elfving 2009 [33]

+ neck: 43/265 (16.2)a + thoracic: 26/265 (9.8)a + neck and thoracic: 116/265 (43.8)a

  

3 (neck, thoracic, neck and thoracic)

 Manchikanti 2003 [41]

+ neck and/or thoracic: 150/300 (50.0)

  

1 (neck and/or thoracic)

 Daviese 1998 [31]

+ neck: 367/2007 (18.3) ♀ 218/367 (59.4) ♂ 149/367 (40.6)

+ shoulder-arm-hand: 331/2007 (16.5) ♀ 199/331 (60.1) ♂ 132/331 (39.9) + pelvic: 112/2007 (5.6) ♀ 71/112 (63.4) ♂ 41/112 (36.6) + buttock-leg-foot: 1006/2007 (50.1) ♀ 595/1006 (59.1) ♂ 411/1006 (40.9)

+ thorax: 203/2007 (10.1) ♀ 118/203 (58.1) ♂ 85/203 (41.9)

+ other body site(s): 1299/2007 (64.7) ♀ 779/1299 (60.0) ♂ 520/1299 (40.0)

6 (neck, shoulder/arm/hand, pelvis, buttock/leg/foot, thorax, other body site(s))

  1. Abbreviations: LBP low back pain, NR not reported, MSK musculoskeletal
  2. a Calculated by us
  3. b Among those with moderate, severe and very severe persistent LBP as those with very mild and mild persistent LBP were omitted in paper
  4. c Information provided by the author of the article
  5. d Headache was not part of our search strategy, but we included the prevalences of headache for the otherwise 5 eligible studies where this was reported
  6. e The study by Rundell et al. also included abdominal pain and the study by Davies et al. included both abdominal pain, pain in the head-face-mouth and anal-perineal-genital pain that is not reported