Skip to main content

Table 3 ROBINS-I assessing risk of bias in non-randomized studies of interventions

From: Functional outcomes and complications of intramedullary fixation devices for Midshaft clavicle fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis

AuthorYearDomain 1: ConfoundingDomain 2:
Selection of participants
Domain 3:
Classification of intervention
Domain 4:
Deviation from interventions
Domain 5:
Missing data Domain
Domain 6:
Measurement of outcomes
Domain 7:
Selection of reported results
ROBINS-I overall
Sonoma CRx
 Zehir et al.201522212222
 King et al.201533212223
 Zehir et al.201533213223
 Calbiyik et al.201621111222
 Zehir S et al.201632212233
Rockwood Pin & Hagie Pin
 Strauss et al.200743312334
 Judd et al.200922111222
 Ferran et al.201022211222
 Mudd et al.201133211323
 Kleweno et al.201132211333
 Millett et al.201133312223
 Payne et al.201132212223
 Frye et al.201233312333
 Marlow et al.201233212223
 Wenninger et al.201332212323
TEN
 Jubel et al.200222112222
 Jubel et al.200223211223
 Jubel et al.200333212233
 Jubel et al.200333112223
 Jubel et al.200523111223
 Kettler et al.200543112224
 Walz et al.200622111222
 Keener et al.200643213233
 Kettler et al.200733212223
 Mueller et al.200722111212
 Witzel200732212223
 Hartmann et al.200833212233
 Frigg et al.200932122233
 Smekal et al.200922111222
 Liu et al.201033212233
 Frigg et al.201122113223
 Chen et al.201122111222
 Assobhi201122211222
 Smekal et al.201122111222
 Kadakia et al.201243212324
 Wijdicks et al.201232312323
 Tarng et al.201233312223
 Chen et al.201233212223
 Prokop et al.201333213233
 Langenhan et al.201423212233
 Saha et al.201432212223
 Shokouh et al.201423212323
 Braun et al.201423212223
 Narsaria et al.201422112222
 Suresha et al.201433212223
 Lu et al.201423112223
 Wang et al.201523112223
 Andrade-Silva et al.201521111212
 van der Meijden et al.201521111212
 Eden et al.201532212223
 Mishra et al.201622212222
 Lechler et al201633212223
 Fuglesang et al.201722112222
 Govindasamy et al.201733213222
 Eickhoff et al.201822112222
 Eisenstein et al.201832212223
 Frima et al.201822212222
 Zhang et al.201923213333
Threaded Pin
 Zenni et al.198144212324
 Grassi et al200133212223
 Bi et al.201522212222
Knowles Pin
 Chu et al200233233233
 Lee et al200732212223
 Lee et al.200833212223
 Wu et al.201332212323
  1. 1 low risk of bias, 2 moderate risk of bias, 3 serious risk of bias, 4 critical risk of bias