Table 1 Characteristics of included studies
Included studies | Cases: MIPO/ORIF | Sex: male/female | Mean age (years): MIPO/ORIF | Follow-up (months) | Fracture type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chiewchantanakit 2015 [21] | 12/16 | 12/16 | 52/62 | NS/NS | Neer: 2,3 |
Fischer 2016 [20] | 30/30 | 16/34 | 57.6/60.6 | 22.8/20.7 | AO: A,B,C |
Gao 2015 [16] | 21/18 | 17/22 | 70/72 | 18.1/18.1 | Neer: 2,3 |
Kim 2019 [28] | 19/17 | NS/NS | 58.7/52.6 | 24/24 | Neer: 2 |
Lin 2014 [22] | 43/43 | 28/58 | 63/61 | 12.6/13.1 | AO: A,B,C |
Liu 2013 [17] | 47/51 | 43/55 | 72.8/49.9 | 18.1/18.1 | Neer: 3,4 |
Liu 2015 [10] | 39/52 | 42/49 | 60.2/61.7 | 24/24 | Neer: 2,3,4 |
Liu 2016 [25] | 33/42 | 28/47 | 50.3/52.1 | 14.2/14.2 | Neer: 2,3 |
Liu 2019 [15] | 45/72 | 44/73 | 62.2/60.1 | NS/NS | Neer: 2,3,4 |
Röderer 2011 [26] | 46/61 | 32/75 | 67.6/65 | 12/12 | AO: A,B,C |
Shang 2013 [19] | 24/54 | 19/59 | 61.6/60 | 33.8/33.8 | Neer: 2,3,4 |
Shen 2018 [23] | 20/26 | 20/26 | 70.4/70.9 | 16.8/16.8 | Neer: 2 |
Sohn 2017 [9] | 45/45 | NS/NS | 61/62.6 | 14.3/15 | Neer: 2,3,4 |
Wang 2012 [18] | 20/20 | 14/26 | 69.6/69.7 | NS/NS | Neer: 2,3 |
Zhang 2018 [24] | 13/20 | 14/19 | 66.1/61.5 | 12.4/11.9 | Neer: 3 |
Zhao 2017 [27] | 17/19 | 21/15 | 64/64.3 | 10/10 | Neer: 2,3,4 |