Skip to main content

Table 4 Overview of current researches that reported more than five cases who underwent a two-stage procedure to a total joint arthroplasty for septic arthritis

From: Outcomes and predictors of treatment failure following two-stage total joint arthroplasty with articulating spacers for evolutive septic arthritis

Study

Num.

Spacer type

Antibiotic in spacer

Duration of antibiotic before reimplantation (weeks)

Period between stages (weeks)

Surgery between stages

Success rate after first-stage surgery

Duration of antibiotic after reimplantation (days)

Mean follow-up (months)

Success rate after prosthesis implantation

Hip

 Anagnostakos 2016 [4]

16

HM

GEN (1.3%) + VAN (5%)

6

13

2 SE+  1 Girdlestone

81%

0

45

87%

 Bauer 2010 [9]

13

NP

Without antibiotics

6

13

NP

NP

NP

60

85%

 Chen 2008 [19]

28

Beads

OXA + GEN

> 4

15

2 Girdlestone

93%

42

77

86%

 Diwanji 2008 [20]

9

HM

VAN (4.9%)

NP

23

1 SE

89%

3 to 5

42

89%

 Fleck 2011 [5]

10

HM

GEN or TOB (9 to 12%) + VAN (5 to 7.5%) + Ancef (5%)

6

44

1 SE

90%

NP

28

100%

 Huang 2010 [21]

14

HM

VAN (10%) + AZT (10%)

1

13

1 SE

93%

3

43

100%

 Kelm 2009 [22]

8

HM

VAN (5%)

6

12

0

100%

NP

12

87.5%

 Papanna 2018 [2]

11

Beads

VAN (5%)

NP

28

NP

NP

NP

70

100%

 Romano 2011 [6]

19

COM

GEN (1.9%) + VAN (5%)

4

22

0

100%

28

57

95%

 Shen 2013 [23]

5

HM

GEN (1.3%) + VAN (8.8%)

> 6

19

0

100%

NP

40

100%

 This study

55

HM

VAN (10–15%) + MER (5–10%)

> 4

23

4 SE

93%

5

62

89%

Knee

 Bauer 2010 [9]

17

NP

Without antibiotics

6

13.3

NP

NP

NP

60

88%

 Kirpalani 2005 [24]

5

Beads

NP

NP

NP

0

100%

0

38.4

100%

 Nazarian 2003 [7]

14

HM

TOB (5–10%) + VAN (2.5%)

> 6

12.4

0

100%

> 185

54

100%

 Shaikh 2000 [8]

13

HM

VAN (10%) + STR (5%)

> 2

22.4

1 SE

92%

> 42

48

100%

 This study

19

HM

VAN (10–15%) + MER (5–10%)

> 4

20.2

0

100%

5

40.3

84%

  1. NP No report, HM Hand-made, COM Commercial, VAN Vancomycin, MER Meropenem, GEN Gentamicin, TOB Tobramycin, STR Streptomycin, OXA Oxacillin, AZT Aztreonam, SE Spacer exchange