Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies

From: The efficacy of intraoperative periarticular injection in Total hip arthroplasty: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author, year

Study design

Enrolled Sample number (G1/G2)

Comparing

Anesthesia

Drug infiltration

Outcome measurement

Quality assessmenta

a

b

c

d

e

f

 

Hirasawa, 2018 [14]

RCT

45/45

PAI, no PAI

GA

Rop 300 mg, Mor 8 mg, Methyl 40 mg, Keto 50 mg, Epi 0.3 mg

V

 

V

   

5

Ban WR,2017 [5]

RCT

43/43

PAI, no PAI

GA

Rop200mg, Keto 30 mg, Epi 0.3 mg

V

 

V

 

V

 

5

Villatte, 2016 [6]

RCT

75/75

PAI, no PAI

GA

Rop 235 mg, Epi 0.5 mg

V

 

V

 

V

 

5

Hofstad, 2015 [10]

RCT

55/54

PAI, no PAI

SA

Rop 300 mg, Epi 0.5 mg

   

V

V

 

5

den Hartog, 2015 [11]

RCT

25/25

PAI, no PAI

SA

Rop 200 mg, Epi 0.5 mg

    

V

V

5

Zoric, 2014 [12]

RCT

29/29

PAI, no PAI

GA

Rop 160 mg

  

V

V

 

V

4

Dobie, 2012 [15]

RCT

46/46

PAI, no PAI

GA

Levo 160 mg

V

   

V

 

5

Murphy, 2012 [7]

RCT

45/46

PAI, no PAI

SA

Bup 150 mg

V

 

V

V

  

5

Lunn, 2011 [13]

RCT

60/60

PAI, no PAI

SA

Rop 200 mg, Epi 1.5 mg

    

V

 

5

Liu, 2011 [8]

RCT

40/40

PAI, no PAI

SA

Bup 30 mg, Mor 5 mg, Bet 1 mg, Epi 0.5 mg

V

    

V

5

Busch, 2010 [9]

RCT

32/31

PAI, no PAI

SA or GA

Rop 40 mg, Keto 30 mg, Epi 0.5 mg

V

     

4

  1. G1 group: study group (PAI); G2 Group: control group (no PAI)
  2. Outcome measure: a = VAS at rest at 24 h, b = VAS at activity at 24 h, c = VAS at rest at 48 h, d = total additional morphine consumption in post-op 24 h, e = Length of hospital stay, f = nausea
  3. Bup bupivacaine, Epi epinephrine, Keto ketorolac, Mor morphine, Rop ropivacaine, Levo levobupivacaine, Bet betamethasone, Methyl methylprednisolone
  4. aJadad score