Study | Patients | Incision | Fixation method | ROM | Major complications | Minor complications | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Flexion | Extension | Pronation | Supination | ||||||
Tarallo et al. (present series) | 63 | 2 | Bone tunnels | 125° | 2° | 73° | 70° | 3(4.5%) PIN transient palsy | 3 (4.7%) Intermittent pain |
(min:110°-max: 135°) | (min:−2-max:15°) | (min:0°-max:90°) | (min:0°-max:90°) | 1 (1.5%) Radio-ulnar synostosis | 6 (9.5%) ROM deficiency < 30% | ||||
97% | 92% | 88.50% | 1(1.5%) Atraumatic re-rupture | 1 (1.5%) Isometric flexion strength defiency< 30° | |||||
1 (1.5%) Isometric supination strength defiency< 60° | |||||||||
3(4.47%) LACBN injury | |||||||||
Grewal et al. (13) | 43 | 2 | Suture anchors | 131.8° ± 9.1 | 1.9° ± 4.6 | 72.4° ± 12.6 | 59.5° ± 11.5 | 1(2.32%) Atraumatic re-rupture | 3(6.9%)LACBN injury |
1(2.32%) HO | |||||||||
47 | 1 | Bone tunnel | 134.5° ± 6.9 | 3.0° ± 4.3 | 76.7° ± 8.2 | 63.9° ± 12.5 | 3(6.38%) Atraumatic re-rupture | 19 (40.42%) LACBN injury | |
1 (2.12%) HO | |||||||||
Gupta at al. (24) | 9 | 1 | Endobutton | 143° | 0° | 77° | 81° | None | None |
(min:70°-max:82°) | (min:78°-max:85°) | ||||||||
Citak et al. (25) | 15 | 1 | Intraosseous screw | 147° | 1.3° | 88° | 89.3° | None | 2(13.3%) LACBN injury |
(min:142.4°-max:150.7°) | (max:-0.6°-min:3.3°) | (min:85.7°-ma:90.3°) | (min:87.9°-max:90.8°) | ||||||
24 | 1 | Suture anchors | 134° | 1.3° | 82.5° | 81.7° | 3(12.5%) re-rupture | 3(12.5%) LACBN injury | |
(min:122.6°-max:145.3°) | (min:-0.2-max:2.7°) | (min:76.2°-max:88.8°) | (min:74.9°-max:88.5°) | 2(8.33%) ROM deficiency < 30% | |||||
25 | 2 | Bone tunnel | 135° | 1° | 85.7° | 84.7° | None | None | |
(min:118.9°-max:151.1°) | (min:-0.6°-max:2.6°) | (min:78.6°-max:92.5°) | (min:77.9°-max:91.5°) | ||||||
Eardley et al. (26) | 14 | 1 | Intraosseous screw | 130° | 0° | 66° | 74° | none | 8(54%) LACBN injury |
(min:110°-145°) | (min:-10°-max:5°) | (min:50°-max:80°) | (min:50°-max:90°) | 1(7.14%) HO | |||||
Johnson et al. (27) | 12 | 1 | Suture anchors | 142° | -2° | 83° | 85° | None | 1(8.33%) LACBN injury |
1(8.33%) HO | |||||||||
14 | 2 | Bone tunnel | 145° | 0° | 80° | 83° | None | 3(21.42%)HO | |
Oke A. Anakwenze et al. (28) | 12 | 2 | Bone tunnel | 153° ± 12.0° | 0° ± 0° | 78.5° ± 9.6° | 78.9° ± 10.0° | None | none |
Amin et al. (29) | 785 | 1 | Suture anchors | 17(2.1%) re-rupture | 77(9.9%) LACBN injury | ||||
Endobutton | 13(1.7%)PIN palsy | 25(3.2%) HO | |||||||
Biotenodesis screw | 49(6.24%) intermittent pain | ||||||||
498 | 2 | Bone tunnel | 3(0.6%) re-rupture | 11(2.2%) LACBN injury | |||||
11(2.2%) synostosis | 36(7.2%) HO | ||||||||
13(1.7%) PIN palsy | |||||||||
David M. Weinstein et al. (30) | 32 | 1 | Suture anchors | 145° ± 8 | 0° ± 3 | 88° ± 10 | 73° ± 10 | None | 2(6.25%) LACBN injury |
1(3.12%) intermittent pain | |||||||||
Olsen JR et al. (31) | 20 | 1 | Cortical button + interference screw | 140° ± 6.2 | 7° ± 5.1 | 79° ± 6.8 | 72° ± 9.5 | 4(20%) PIN palsy | 3(18%) LACBN injury |
17 | 1 | Suture anchors | 139° ± 5.6 | 5° ± 3.9 | 75° ± 9.2 | 76° ± 5.3 | 1(6%) PIN palsy | None |