Skip to main content

Table 1 Description of the sample and methods of the studies included and hip OA assessment

From: Neuroimmune expression in hip osteoarthritis: a systematic review

Author, year

Sample Size

No

Sample collection

Age

Sex (No of men)

Definition of:

OA

C

OA

C

OA

C

OA

C

Pombo-Suarez, 2009 [20]

22

11

11

Surgery

NI

NI

NI

NI

Clinical, imagiological and histological

Non-OA hip fracture

Koorts, 2012 [16]

26

7

19

Puncture

NI

NI

NI

NI

Clinical and imagiological

Normal X-ray; No inflammation

Granchi, 2006 [12]

128

39

20

Puncture

56 (13)

60 (12)

13

14

Clinical and imagiological

Clinically healthy donnors

Granchi, 2003 [13]

112

22

39

Puncture

60 (3)

52 (3)

8

15

Clinical and imagiological

Clinically healthy donnors

Hashimoto, 2013 [14]

35

7

3

Surgery

52.7 (37–73)a

28 (15–44)a

5

4

Clinical, imagiological and histological

No tissue degeneration

Abrams, 2014 [10]

34

17

17

Puncture

59.2 (11.9)

38.3 (11.1)

9

5

Clinical and imagiological

Normal X-ray

Pape, 2000 [19]

105

22

20

Puncture

47 (19)

22-26b

12

20

Clinical

NI

Dallos, 2009 [11]

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

Clinical and imagiological

NI

Hulejova, 2007 [7]

85

55

30

Surgery/Puncture

56.4 (10.6)

67.5 (9.5)

9

8

Clinical and imagiological

Healthy; No OA on X-ray; No inflammation

Shi, 2002 [22]

NI

12

10

Surgery

71 (8)

NI

2

4

Clinical and imagiological

No metabolic disease; No OA diagnosis; No OA on surgery

Kumarasinghe, 2012 [17]

NI

5

5

Surgery

67 (12)

81 (6)

0

0

Clinical and imagiological

Non-OA femoral neck fracture?

Lavigne, 2004 [18]

NI

19

11

Surgery

NI

NI

NI

NI

Clinical and imagiological

NI

Saxler, 2007 [5]

6

3

3

Surgery

74

65

0

0

Clinical and imagiological

No pain or degeneration

Sanchez-Sabaté, 2009́ [21]

35

16

11

Surgery

66.9 (7)

42.3 (11.2)

7

7

Clinical and imagiological

No metabolic disease

Takeshita, 2012 [23]

62

50

12

Surgery

61.3 (48–80)a

79 (63–90)a

4

3

Clinical and imagiological

No clinical or imagiological OA

Verdier, 2005 [24]

9

6

3

Surgery

69-85b

76-86b

9

9

Clinical and imagiological

Healthy patients with hip fracture

Hopwood, 2007 [15]

35

24

21

Surgery

49-85b

43-85b

10

10

Clinical and imagiological

No bone disease

  1. All as Mean (Standard Deviation), unless otherwise indicated. OA Osteoarthritis, C Controls, NI No Information. aMean (range). bMin-Max