Skip to main content

Table 1 Infection eradication rates after revision arthroplasty for periprosthetic shoulder infection

From: Does exchange arthroplasty of an infected shoulder prosthesis provide better eradication rate and better functional outcome, compared to a permanent spacer or resection arthroplasty? a systematic review

Author

Year

Number of patients

Infections eradicated

Rate (%)

Follow-up (months)

Min

Max

Mean

Resection arthroplasty

Sperling [27]

2001

21

15

71.4

33.6

157.2

78

Coste [21]

2004

10

7

70.0

12

96

32

Maynou [28]

2006

10

10

100.0

  

44

Braman [2]

2006

7

7

100.0

12

42

20.4

Rispoli [29]

2007

13

13

100.0

  

8.3

Verhelst [9]

2011

11

9

81.8

  

46.4

Weber [10]

2011

5

5

100.0

14.4

120

48

RomanĂ² [30]

2012

6

6

100.0

24

98

41.1

Total Mean (SD)

83

72

86.7

19.2 (9.4)

102.6 (41.9)

39.8 (20.8)

Single-stage arthroplasty

Sperling [27]

2001

2

1

50

9

120

57.6

Coste [21]

2004

3

3

100

12

96

32.0

Ince [16]

2005

14

14

100

13

159

69.6

Cuff [7]

2007

10

10

100

25

66

43.0

Beekman [14]

2010

11

10

90.9

12

36

22.4

Klatte [31]

2013

35

33

94.3

13.2

159

56.4

Total Mean (SD)

75

71

94.7

14.0 (5.6)

106 (49.8)

46.8 (17.6)

Two-stage arthroplasty

Sperling [27]

2001

3

3

100

26.4

106.8

57.6

Seitz [32]

2002

8

8

100

36

96

56

Jerosh [3]

2003

8

8

100

6

30

 

Coste [21]

2004

10

6

60

12

96

32

Cuff [7]

2007

12

12

100

25

66

43

Strickland [8]

2008

19

12

63.2

24

80

35

Themistocleous [33]

2008

2

2

100

15

26

22

Coffey [34]

2010

12

12

100

10

29

18.3

Stine [35]

2010

15

15

100

  

27.6

Jawa [36]

2011

15

14

93.3

12

69

27.6

Sabesan [37]

2011

17

16

94.1

22

80

46.2

Weber [10]

2011

4

4

100

14.4

120

48

RomanĂ² [30]

2012

17

17

100

24

98

41.1

Total Mean (SD)

142

129

90.8

18.9 (8.7)

74.7 (31.8)

37.9 (12.8)

Permanent spacer

Jerosh [3]

2003

2

2

100

6

30

18

Coste [21]

2004

1

1

100

12

96

32

Themistocleous [33]

2008

9

9

100

15

26

22

Coffey [34]

2010

4

4

100

16

25

19.25

Stine [35]

2010

15

15

100

  

28.8

Jawa [36]

2011

12

10

83.3

12

69

27.6

Verhelst [9]

2011

10

10

100

  

46.4

RomanĂ² [30]

2012

15

14

93.3

24

98

41.1

Total Mean (SD)

68

65

95.6

14.2 (5.9)

57.3 (34.8)

31 (9.8)