Skip to main content

Table 7 Physician responses to selected survey questions (acetate vs. phosphate, and diabetes). Acetate vs. Phosphate, & Diabetes, Contingency Tables

From: Variations in corticosteroid/anesthetic injections for painful shoulder conditions: comparisons among orthopaedic surgeons, rheumatologists, and physical medicine and primary-care physicians

Question #5a – Were you aware that there are acetate and phosphate types of corticosteroids?

 

Orthopaedists

PCSMs/PMRs

Rheumatologists

TOTAL

Yes

55(59.1%)

28(76%)

16(80%)

99

No

36(38.7%)

9(24%)

4(20%)

49

No Answer

2(2.2%)

0(0%)

0(0%)

2

TOTAL

93

37

20

150*

Question #5b – If yes, which type is more soluble?

 

Orthopaedists

PCSMs/PMRs

Rheumatologists

TOTAL

Phosphate

30(32.2%)

12(32.4%)

5(25%)

47

Acetate

6(6.5%)

3(8.1%)

2(10%)

11

Don't Know

57(61.3%)

22(59.5)

13(65%)

92

TOTAL

93

37

20

150*

Question #6 – Were you aware that acetate vs. phosphate corticosteroids may have different degrees of local and systemic absorption, and differences in duration of their anti-inflammatory affect?

 

Orthopaedists

PCSMs/PMRs

Rheumatologists

TOTAL

Yes

40(43%)

19(51.4%)

10(50%)

69

No

51(54.8%)

16(43.2%)

10(50%)

77

No Answer

2(2.2%)

2(5.4%)

0(0%)

4

TOTAL

93

37

20

150*

Question #7 – Do you ever use acetate-type corticosteroids (instead of phosphate-types) for treating specific shoulder conditions?

 

Orthopaedists

PCSMs/PMRs

Rheumatologists

TOTAL

Yes

35(37.6%)

13(35.1%)

3(15%)

51

No

49(52.7)

21(56.8%)

13(65%)

83

No Answer

9(9.7%)

3(8.1%)

4(20%)

16

TOTAL

93

37

20

150*

Question #8 – Do you ever use phosphate-type corticosteroids (instead of acetate-types) for treating specific shoulder conditions?

 

Orthopaedists

PCSMs/PMRs

Rheumatologists

TOTAL

Yes

21(22.6%)

9(24.3%)

3(15%)

33

No

66(71%)

26(70.3%)

17(85%)

109

No Answer

6(6.4%)

2(5.4%)

0(0%)

8

TOTAL

93

37

20

150*

Question #9 – Do you use a different type of corticosteroids for injecting the shoulder region of diabetic patients?

 

Orthopaedists

PCSMs/PMRs

Rheumatologists

TOTAL

Yes

8(8.6%)

5(13.5%)

2(10%)

15

No

85(91.4%)

31(83.8%)

18(90%)

134

No Answer

0(0%)

1(2.7%)

0(0%)

1

TOTAL

93

37

20

150*

  1. * The total number of physicians represents the 150 of the 169 early responders who actually treat painful shoulder conditions with corticosteroids (93 orthopaedic surgeons, 37 PCSMs/PMRs, and 20 rheumatologists.)