Skip to main content

Table 1 Reported reliability of different fracture classifications for distal radius fractures in adults

From: Classification of distal radius fractures in children: good inter- and intraobserver reliability, which improves with clinical experience

Reference

Classification

Interobserever reliability

Intraobserver reliability

Kreder et al 1996

AO type

0.68

0.86

 

AO group

0.48

 
 

AO subgroup

0.33

0.42

Ploegmakers et al 2007

AO/ASIF

0.10*

0.52

 

Frykman

0.10*

0.26

 

Fernandez

0.16*

0.42

 

Older

0.15*

0.27

Jin et al 2007

AO type

0.45

0.49

 

AO group

0.25

0.36

 

Frykman

0.36

0.54

 

Cooney group

0.59

0.72

 

Cooney subgroup

0.36

0.42

Andersen et al 1996

Frykman

0.36

0.48

 

Melone

0.34

0.48

 

Mayo

0.43

0.44

 

AO type

0.64

0.66

 

AO Group

0.30

0.37

 

AO subgroup

0.25

0.31

Flinkkilä et al 1998

AO/ASIF modified

0.23

 

Belloti 2008

AO/ASIF

0.27

0.49

 

Frykman

0.24

0.55

 

Fernandez

0.34

0.59

 

Universal (Cooney)

0.40

0.61

  1. Kappa coefficients unless where indicated
  2. * Spearman rank correlation coefficient