Skip to main content

Table 6 The found literature on comparison between one-stage and two-stage bilateral THA.

From: Simultaneous bilateral hip replacement reveals superior outcome and fewer complications than two-stage procedures: a prospective study including 1819 patients and 5801 follow-ups from a total joint replacement registry

N

Authors

Year

Period

Study

Number of pat.

Inter-operative days

FU (months)

Functional outcome

Complications

Pro/contra

1

Alfaro-Adriàn

1999

1989-95

1/2 stage

202(95/107)

0/60-730(300)

0

similar

>blood transfusions

pro: <hospital stay, costs

2

Berend KR

2007

1997-05

1/2 stage

277(167/110)

0/14-730(240)

30(6-108)

early: <function

>blood transfusions >revisions

contra: <reimbursement

3

Bhan

2006

1996-01

1/2 stage

168(83/85)

0/90-210

60(48-96)

similar

>blood transfusions

pro: < hospital stay

4

Eggli

1996

1982-92

1/2 stage

255(64/63/128)

0/>42/42-180

>18

similar; >stiff hip

similar

pro: <hospital stay, costs

5

McBryde

2007

1994-06

1/2 stage

92(37/55)

0/1-365

15(1-60)/34(1-131)

early better

similar, >intubation time

pro: <hospital stay, costs

6

Parvizi

2006

1997-04

1/2 stage

196(98/98)

0/25-303(138)

0

similar

<blood transfusions <complications

pro: <costs, >rehabilitation

7

Reuben

1998

1991-94

1/2 stage/unilat

154(7/8/139)

0/7/unilat

0

-

-

pro: < costs

8

Salvati

1978

1970-76

1/2 stage

461(122/134/205)

0/same hosp/2nd hosp

36(12-96)

similar

similar

pro: <hospital stay, costs, OP time

9

Schiessel

2005

1996-02

1/2 stage

30(15/15)

0/120-665(485)

66(SD 19.5)

similar (subjectively>)

similar

pro: <hospital stay, costs

10

Shih

1985

1979-82

1/2 stage

35(20/15)

0/14-365

12/17.7

similar but <ROM

similar

pro: <hospital stay, OP time

  1. The column "Study" shows the studied subgroups. The column "Number of patients" represents the total number of studied patients and number of subgroups in parentheses. The inter-operative interval for the subgroups is shown in the column "Inter-operative days" with mean values for the two-stage subgroup included in parentheses, if available. In the column "FU (month)" the mean follow-up time is given with the range of follow-up time or standard deviation (SD) in parentheses, if available. Note that ">" and "<" mean "more/better" respectively "less/worse" in the simultaneous subgroup.