Scapular deformity in obstetric brachial plexus palsy and the Hueter-Volkmann law; a retrospective study
© van Gelein Vitringa et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 26 June 2012
Accepted: 14 March 2013
Published: 22 March 2013
The Hueter-Volkmann law describes growth principles around joints and joint deformation. It states that decreased stress leads to increased growth and that excessive stress leads to growth retardation. Aim of this study was to test the possible results of this principle by measuring the effect of dorsal humeral head subluxation on scapular growth in children with Obstetrical Brachial Plexus Lesions (OBPL). According to the Hueter-Volkmann law, subluxation should result in decrease of growth of the dorsal length of the scapula (by increased dorsal pressure) and increase of the ventral length (decreased pressure).
58 children (mean age 20 months, range 1-88 month) with unilateral OBPL and good quality MRI of both shoulders were included. On MRI, humeral head subluxation, joint deformation, and ventral and dorsal scapular lengths were measured. Data were expressed as a ratio of the normal side.
In affected scapulas both ventral and dorsal side were smaller compared to the normal side. Reduction of growth on the affected side was more marked on the dorsal side than on the ventral side (6.5 mm respectively 4.5 mm, p < 0.001). The balance of growth reduction as expressed by the ratio of ventral and dorsal length was strongly related to subluxation (R2 = 0.33, p < 0.001) and age (R2 = 0.19, p < 0.001).
The Hueter-Volkmann law is incompletely active in subluxated shoulders in OBPL. Dorsal subluxation indeed leads to decrease of growth of the dorsal length of the scapula. However, decreased stress did not lead to increased growth of the ventral length of the scapula.
KeywordsHueter-Volkmann law Obstetric brachial plexus lesion Scapular bone growth Shoulder deformity
One of the principles that appears to partially govern bone growth is the Hueter-Volkmann “law“. More a principle than a law, it was formulated to describe growth principles around immature joints and is paraphrased stating that excessive pressure to a part of the joint leads to local growth retardation and reduced pressure to a part of the joint leads to local growth acceleration.
Although in its paraphrased form it describes the relation between pressure and bone growth, the concept of pressure was originally less stressed by Hueter. In the original 1862 article Hueter stresses more the influence of movement and joint position on joint form. Sentences giving his ideas in this 36 pages article written in the extended style of the epoch are (authors translation): (p485) “In this flexion position only the posterior parts of the tibia are in contact with the joint surfaces of the femoral condyles while the anterior parts of the tibia are not in contact with the femur and thereby are free of the pressure that is resting on the posterior parts. Because of this pressure difference the anterior part develops a relative larger length growth of the diaphyses than the posterior part. while the epiphyseal cartilage … shows no difference in height between anterior and posterior sections …”. In another part of his article: (p502) “In what I said describe above, I have tried to show the influence of movements on the various surfaces of the knee joint and on their form and remodelling”. Hueter stated more the influence of movements and position, but indirectly explains it in terms of pressure.
Originally formulated by Hueter, Volkmann’s name was later added to this growth principle, by his statements on the effect of tension and compression on the epiphyseal plate, coincidentally in the same year 1862[2, 3]. The Hueter-Volkmann law was later on generalised beyond joint growth and extended to describe growth and remodelling in long bones. Since a rigid application of the principle, that excessive pressure leads to growth arrest would preclude all remodelling, it was adapted by suggesting that an increase in stress would first lead to increased growth and excessive stress to retardation[5–8].
The Hueter-Volkmann law is well known from orthopaedic textbooks but its quantitative basis is weak. In order to test the possible results of the principle we performed a study on the effect of subluxation on bone growth and joint deformation in shoulders of children with an Obstetric Brachial Plexus Lesion (OBPL), a lower motor neuron disorder. This neural lesion often results in dorsal humeral head subluxation (subsequently referred to as subluxation) and deformation of the shoulder. In the normal shoulder the glenoid is in mild retroversion with consequently the dorsal length of the scapula being slightly shorter than the ventral side. When the shoulder subluxates retroversion increases and deformation of the normal flat/concave glenoid develops.
Based on the Hueter-Volkmann law, we stated the hypothesis that with increasing dorsal subluxation of the humeral head and thus presumably more pressure on the dorsal side and less pressure on the ventral side, the growth of the dorsal length of the scapula would decrease and that the growth of ventral length of the scapula would increase.
Scapular growth, subluxation and joint deformation
Results are presented as mean (SD). Age and inter-individual differences were corrected by expressing scapular length of the affected side as a ratio of the normal side. Data were analysed using SPSS (version 15.0). Differences were tested using t-test and intra-variance measures with ANOVA. The relation between growth and subluxation was analysed using regression analysis. P < 0.05 was considered to be significant and all analyses were two-tailed.
In total 58 children with unilateral OBPL were analysed. In 25 children the left side was affected, in 33 the right side. Narakas classes were: class I, 34 children; class II, 12 children and class III, 12 children. There were no complications related to the MR imaging protocol.
Values of scapular length on ventral and dorsal side of affected and normal shoulder
Regression models for scapular length on ventral and dorsal side of normal and affected shoulder related to age (months), all significantly related to age (p < 0.001)
Qualitative measurements, as defined by Birch, showed increasing deformation related to changes in the VS/DS ratio. A biconcave glenoid (Birch class 3) was related to more severe dorsal growth reduction. Mean VS/DS ratio in class 1: 1.05 (0.05), in class 2: 1.07(0.05) and in class 3: 1.15(0.05) (p < 0.001).
This study is the first attempt to qualify the possible effects of the Hueter-Volkmann law in the immature shoulder joints. We tried to demonstrate and to qualify the Hueter-Volkmann law (stating that an increase of pressure leads to reduction of bone growth and decrease of pressure leads to stimulation of bone growth) in the development of scapular deformity in children with dorsal subluxation of the humeral head caused by OPBL. We assumed that dorsal subluxation of the humeral head in OPBL leads to increase of pressure at the dorsal side of the glenoid and decrease of pressure at the ventral side of the glenoid. According to the Hueter-Volkmann law, we hypothesized that this aberrant pressure would lead to decreased growth of the dorsal scapula and increased growth of the ventral scapula. However, in contrast to our hypothesis, we could not fully confirm this law in this study of shoulder deformities in children with OPBL. We showed that growth reduction was present both at the ventral and dorsal side of the scapula, with most of the reduction on the dorsal side. On the ventral side of the scapula, where glenohumeral pressure is reduced, there was no increase in growth.
We used a clinical neuromuscular model of subluxation of the shoulder caused by OPBL to qualify the Hueter-Volkmann law. However, we could not prove the Hueter-Volkmann law exactly in our neuromuscular model. It may be questioned why the Hueter-Volkmann law does not fully apply for children with subluxation resulting from OPBL. Hueter describes in his original study the idea that movements and forces are factors influencing joint form and illustrates this on the knee joint. In an experimental setting, growth plates of various animals in various locations show the same reaction to altered mechanical compression and distraction forces. Scapular growth is to some extent different from growth of long bones. It resembles growth of the acetabulum and iliac bone. In the scapula, two growth plates are present: a growth plate along the margo medialis and a growth plate at the glenoid. These two growth plates contribute both to scapular growth but their relative contributions are unknown. This influences the coefficients in the equations on scapular length. It seems intuitively correct to assume that subluxation causes growth reduction primarily on the glenoid growth plate. This means that the coefficients in the equations are larger than given: if the glenoid side contributes 50% of total growth it would result in doubling of the coefficients and even stronger evidence of our findings. Moreover, forces in a neuromuscular disorder differ from physiological forces acting on the joints of long bones. Not only the direction but the nature of forces active is relevant: static compression decreases biosynthetic activity, whereas cyclic hydrostatic pressure increases activity. The combined effect of subluxation and abnormal movement caused by neuromuscular dysfunction results in reduced cyclic loading and more static compression on the glenoid, both leading to a reduced local growth and subsequent joint deformation.
Contrary to the Hueter-Volkmann law stating that a reduction of pressure leads to stimulation, we could not find a stimulating effect on growth of the ventral side following reduced ventral “pressure” in case of dorsal subluxation. Growth reduction is present on both the ventral and dorsal side of the scapula, but differs with most of the reduction on the dorsal side. This asymmetry in reduction affects joint development and leads to glenoid and humeral head deformation. Glenoid form and orientation are determined by the combined growth of ventral and dorsal length. Subluxation of the humeral head leads to changes in this balance, leading to increased retroversion or glenoid deformation. In addition we showed that the VS/DS ratio, the balance between ventral and dorsal length of the scapula, is strongly related to the extent of joint subluxation (R2 = 0.33, p < 0.001).
The relation between stress and growth is complex: as mentioned in the introduction an increase in stress would first lead to increased growth and excessive stress would lead to retardation[5–8]. However, with no or very little stress growth proceeds at a basal rate[5, 7], which we think is the fact on the ventral side of the by OBPL affected scapula. In the normal scapula optimal pressure at both ventral and dorsal side results in a higher (and physiological) growth rate, resulting in optimal and symmetrical lengthening. On the dorsal side of the affected scapula excessive stress of the subluxated humeral head leads to retardation of growth, to the extend that it comes under the basal growth rate at the ventral side. To summarize: growth rate on ventral and dorsal side are reduced because of the paresis in OBPL, on the ventral side because of stress reduction, while on the dorsal side growth is even more severely reduced because of increased stress.
In an effort to demonstrate and qualify the Hueter-Volkmann law in children with OPBL, we encountered some strong points and some weak points. Strong points of our study are the homogeneous set of infants and children, the imaging technique suited for cartilaginous structures and for contralateral comparison. We did not measure growth intra-individually over time, so growth was estimated by the inter-individual differences in age. All measurements and ratio-calculations were intra-individually as we could compare affected scapulas to the normal contralateral scapulas. However, our study has some limitations. One limitation is that scapular growth is different from growth of long bones, as stated earlier. As explained, the presence of two growth plates could theoretically make our findings stronger. Another limitation is that measurements were done on transversal MRI projections that were standard used for imaging of shoulder deformity in OBPL[9, 11]. However in OBPL both size and tilt of the affected scapula are different and this affects length measurements. The affected scapula is tilted in several planes. In the coronal plane the inferior angle of the scapula is tilted medially-upward. This tilt leads to a systematic overestimation of the lengths measured on the affected side. This means that growth reduction is larger than described in this study and our findings would even be stronger.
In conclusion: the paraphrased Hueter-Volkmann law applies partially for children with dorsal subluxated shoulders in OBPL. Dorsal subluxation in OBPL shoulders is associated with decrease of growth of both the dorsal and ventral length of the scapula. Decreased stress did not lead to increased growth of the ventral length of the scapula. According to this study the Hueter-Volkmann law for the subluxated shoulders should be: excessive pressure to a part of the joint leads to more growth retardation of that part of the joint and to less growth retardation of the not stressed part of the joint.
Obstetric brachial plexus lesion
Dorsal subluxation of the humeral head
Distance between the medial side of the scapula and the subchondral glenoid at the ventral side of the scapula
Distance between the medial side of the scapula and the subchondral glenoid at the dorsal side of the scapula.
We are grateful to Mr. B. Knol (medical statistic department of the VU medical center) for statistical advice.
- Hueter C: Anatomische Studien an den Extremitätengelenken Neugeborener und Erwachsener. Archiv fuer pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und fuer klinische Medicin. 1862, 26: 484-519.
- Gocht H: Ätiologie, Pathogenese und Therapie der Deformitäten im allgemeinen. Hoffa Orthopädisch Chirurgie. Edited by: Gocht H. 1920, Stuttgart: Ferdinand Enke, 8-74.
- Mehlman CT, Araghi A, Roy DR: Hyphenated history: the Hueter-Volkmann law. Am J Orthop (Belle Mead NJ). 1997, 26: 798-800.
- Wenger DR, Rang M: The art and practice of children's orthopaedics. 1993, New York: Raven press
- Frost HM: Skeletal structural adaptations to mechanical usage (SATMU): 3. The hyaline cartilage modeling problem. Anat Rec. 1990, 226: 423-432. 10.1002/ar.1092260404.View ArticlePubMed
- Stokes IA: Mechanical effects on skeletal growth. J Musculoskelet Neuronal Interact. 2002, 2: 277-280.PubMed
- Rauch F: Bone growth in length and width: the Yin and Yang of bone stability. J Musculoskelet Neuronal Interact. 2005, 5: 194-201.PubMed
- Mau H: Specification of corresponding growth laws of Hueter-Volkmann and Pauwels (growth deformities) and their relation to deformities caused by loading. Z Orthop Ihre Grenzgeb. 1984, 122: 293-298. 10.1055/s-2008-1044629.View ArticlePubMed
- Pearl ML: Shoulder problems in children with brachial plexus birth palsy: evaluation and management. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2009, 17: 242-254.PubMed
- Narakas AO: Obstetrical brachial plexus injuries. The Paralysed Hand. Edited by: Lamb D. 1987, Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 116-135.
- Waters PM, Smith GR, Jaramillo D: Glenohumeral deformity secondary to brachial plexus birth palsy. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1998, 80: 668-677.PubMed
- Birch R: Birth lesions of the brachial plexus. Surgical disorders of the peripheral nerves. Edited by: Birch R, Bonney G, Wynn Parry CB. 1998, London: Churchill Livingstone, 209-233.
- Stokes IA, Aronsson DD, Dimock AN, Cortright V, Beck S: Endochondral growth in growth plates of three species at two anatomical locations modulated by mechanical compression and tension. J Orthop Res. 2006, 24: 1327-1334. 10.1002/jor.20189.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMed
- Ogden JA, Phillips SB: Radiology of postnatal skeletal development VII. The scapula. Skeletal Radiol. 1983, 9: 157-169. 10.1007/BF00352547.View ArticlePubMed
- Gray ML, Pizzanelli AM, Grodzinsky AJ, Lee RC: Mechanical and physiochemical determinants of the chondrocyte biosynthetic response. J Orthop Res. 1988, 6: 777-792. 10.1002/jor.1100060602.View ArticlePubMed
- Smith RL, Rusk SF, Ellison BE, Wessells P, Tsuchiya K, Carter DR: In vitro stimulation of articular chondrocyte mRNA and extracellular matrix synthesis by hydrostatic pressure. J Orthop Res. 1996, 14: 53-60. 10.1002/jor.1100140110.View ArticlePubMed
- Nath RK, Paizi M: Scapular deformity in obstetric brachial plexus palsy: a new finding. Surg Radiol Anat. 2007, 29: 133-140. 10.1007/s00276-006-0173-1.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMed
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2474/14/107/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.